News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:China's New Rare Earth and Magnet Restrictions Threaten U... by CuriouslyC on Sunday October 12, 2025 @12:57AM (#45555360)
Please at least edit the AI answer to look like you tried a little bit.
Re:China's New Rare Earth and Magnet Restrictions Threaten U... by throwaway-0001 on Sunday October 12, 2025 @01:00AM (#45555375)
Edited. But why you so against being AI than making an argument to that? At least the AI is showing up what’s inaccurate and most comments get it wrong.
Re:China's New Rare Earth and Magnet Restrictions Threaten U... by LexiMax on Sunday October 12, 2025 @01:26AM (#45555494)
The grandparent comment isn't "against AI" - it's against low-effort participation. When you paste raw AI output without even reading it critically, you're essentially saying "I care so little about this discussion that I won't spend 60 seconds engaging with it myself."

You ask why we should care whether it's AI-generated. Here's why: unedited AI responses often contain hallucinations, miss context from the thread, and make arguments the poster doesn't actually understand or stand behind. When challenged, can you defend the points "you" made? Do you even know what they are?

More fundamentally, forums like HN are built on human discourse - people sharing their knowledge, experience, and perspectives. When you automate your participation, you're taking from the community (reading others' contributions) while giving nothing of yourself back. You're treating other humans as if they exist to process your LLM's output.

If a topic matters enough to you to hit "reply," it should matter enough to formulate your own response. If it doesn't, just move on. Nobody benefits from discussions cluttered with unvetted AI text from people who couldn't be bothered to engage.

---

Thus spake Claude Sonnet.

Re:China's New Rare Earth and Magnet Restrictions Threaten U... by leobg on Sunday October 12, 2025 @01:43AM (#45555594)
A fellow Nietzschean? :)
Re:China's New Rare Earth and Magnet Restrictions Threaten U... by LVB on Sunday October 12, 2025 @01:34AM (#45555541)
>At least the AI is showing up what’s inaccurate and most comments get it wrong.

And we know AI is right, how?

Many folks don't like these AI comments because we're all awash in AI, all day every day. The search results, blogs, news, ads, everything is seriously tilting AI, and it can be dull. I could easily ask ChatGPT or Claude the same thing you did. But a definitely human-written comment, warts and errors and all, can be more interesting.

Re:China's New Rare Earth and Magnet Restrictions Threaten U... by stirfish on Sunday October 12, 2025 @12:54AM (#45555345)
Are you a bot
Re:China's New Rare Earth and Magnet Restrictions Threaten U... by throwaway-0001 on Sunday October 12, 2025 @12:57AM (#45555359)
Anything I said was wrong? First commenter was wrong about something, and just raised up. Stick to the topic if you have anything to add id say.
Re:China's New Rare Earth and Magnet Restrictions Threaten U... by stirfish on Sunday October 12, 2025 @01:17AM (#45555457)
You're absolutely right. It's not that you're a bot — it's that nobody wants to spend the time engaging with a comment you didn't make the effort to write yourself.