This is, and the rudeness is warranted here, a breathtakingly stupid thing to claim. Are you just not looking at what the Republican party has become, or do you think the full-throated support of Trump's policies by the Republican party doesn't imply the Republican party's policies are Trump's policies?
The idea that the Democratic Party and Trump Party's economic and foreign policies have no daylight between them is laughable.
From the 100% tariffs, the plans to pave over Gaza and build hotels, slashing and burning social safety nets, threatening to annex Canada and Greenland, canceling chip fab plans in the US, the list goes on forever.
There.
> Why tariffs have crossed a line is because the Republicans seem to have forgotten that protecting the economic order is the point of culture war issues.
It does not say it is not neoliberalism. Just that it is tactical mistake related to culture war.
- Israel
- The rest of the Middle East
- Ukraine
- NATO
- China (tariffs notwithstanding)
- Russia
Even on something like immigration, the ICE Gestapo are only really an escalation of what both parties have been doing. Kamala's immigration plan in the last election cycle was esentially identical to Trump's 2020 platform. Obama was called, among other things, the deporter-in-chief (eg [1]). Biden blocked more asylum seekers under Title 42 than Trump did in his first term.
[1]: https://ohss.dhs.gov/topics/immigration/yearbook/2019/table3...
NATO - Trump and republicans are intentionally trying to dismantle it. Democrats dont.
Russia - Republicans admire what Russia stands for. Democrats dont.
And the claim that parties are the same on immigration is beyond absurd too. Yes they are fully easily distinguishable. It does not mean that Democrats are like the caricature conservatives make with "anything goes" policies. Just because they are not in complete extreme does not mean they are the same. And they were definitely not creating the "you can arrest people on their skin color alone" philosophy conservatives use.
What is different in Ukraine now vs under Biden? The war hasn't ended. We haven't stopped supplying Ukraine.
The US was always going to support Ukraine no matter who was in office at the time the war started. The only reason you heard noise from the Republicans against it was because Russia invaded when Biden was in office. That's literally it.
> NATO - Trump and republicans are intentionally trying to dismantle it. Democrats dont.
How exactly? Trump has forced NATO members to spend more on their military (~2% GDP, as per the NATO charter). NATO expansion into the former Warsaw bloc countries began under Clinton, continued under Bush and kept going under Obama. There's no difference here.
> Russia - Republicans admire what Russia stands for. Democrats dont.
I don't really care about rhetoric. People say things. It doesn't mean a lot. Not compared to what they do anyway. It's a bit like Erdogan in Turkey waving his fist in the air saying "I'm so mad at you, Israel". Is he actually? No. Turkey could collapse Israel's economy overnight if they really wanted to.
> Just because they are not in complete extreme does not mean they are the same. And they were definitely not creating the "you can arrest people on their skin color alone" philosophy conservatives use.
Assuming we have elections again and assuming Democrats try to win a presidential election (they did not try to win 2024) and assuming we get another Democratic administration, watch what they roll back of Republican policy. Historically, it's been very little.
Remember Trump's 2017 tax cuts? What of that got rolled back? The Democrats held the House, Senate and the White House for Biden's first 2 years. They could've claimed they needed to to pay for COVID economic relief.
Bush created ICE in 2003. Remember how Obama disbanded ICE? Oh wait, Biden disbanded ICE? Oh wait... And it's not like disbanding ICE is a new idea. It's not.
The job of the Democrats is to use the idea of defending institutions as an excuse to do nothing.
What is different is that USA did actually stopped supporting Ukraine entirely for months. What also happened is that USA negotiated with Putin only, consistently putting Ukraine at disadvantage in those pretend peace deals. What also happened was that USA was giving Putin everything he wanted both in appearance and reality. What was also different was naked attempt to extort Ukraine and give them noting while giving their territory to Russia while demanding they give minerals to USA in exchange of "protection".
The approach and support in this completely is completely different from before. Biden mistake was to disallow attacks on Russian territory before Trump could take over and turn toward Russia he and his people admire so much.
> Trump has forced NATO members to spend more on their military
Trump made NATO members not believe USA will hold their part of the agreement. Trump lied about NATO and NATO members. I mean, others already helped America in their war and Trump clearly said he wont reciprocate.
> NATO expansion into the former Warsaw bloc countries began under Clinton, continued under Bush and kept going under Obama. There's no difference here.
Yes, eastern countries wanted to go to NATO, lobbed a lot and gained the security they craved.
> People say things. It doesn't mean a lot.
It does mean a lot, actually.
Funny, ICE was not doing pure racial profiling it is doing now. Pretending things are the same under both administration is just pure lie.
America is a one-party state. That party is neoliberalism. On economics and foreign policy there's almost no daylight between the major parties in the US and really foreign policy is economics. Imperialism is the highest form of capitalism.
Political discourse is dominated by culture war issues not economics. Race, gender, sexual oreintation, immigration status, etc are intentional distractions designed to divide the working class while the government steals from you to give it to the wealthy. As LBJ put it:
> “If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you.”
Southern states were so deeply concerned that poor white people would unit with freed slaves they went out of their way to sow these kinds of racial divisions.
Why tariffs have crossed a line is because the Republicans seem to have forgotten that protecting the economic order is the point of culture war issues. You're not meant to actually start messing twith the economic order. Trade is so intertwined on the global stage that no country stands self-sufficient. China can wield an extremely large stick here. Rare earths are just the tip of the iceberg.
The US produces very little now and that's mostly weapons (and some commercial airplanes). You might say tech products but they're almost all produced in China. We have a dysfunctional economy that teeters on the brink of collapse where basics like food, water and shelter are getting out of reach for many people. Take out data centers being built and our economy is in decline and that's another theft from the public too as we're all paying for the electricity. Now that might be fine if those AI data centers actually produced something but... they don't.
The capitalist dream here seems to be to produce AI to displace workers but where does it end? Who buys your stuff if nobody has a job and those who do have no disposable income?
AI data centers, weapons and private equity firms. That's the modern US economy.
Compare that to China where the government is building infrastructure at an incredible rate and is investing in public services.
I feel like the epitaph for the United States of America will be something like "For a brief time we created a lot of shareholder value."