News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by dos1 on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:07PM (#4554583)
Apple's incessant need to obsolete their old operating systems is surprising to me. I would think this would hurt their overall adoption rates (especially long term) as people get sick of constantly upgrading their OS and dealing with any fallout that results.

I for one will never run OSX again due to the constant need for upgrades. I have one of the original Intel MacBooks (with the Core Duo) and after upgrading to 10.6 my wireless card quit working. Rolling back to 10.5 fixed it. Although, with their popularity skyrocketing, maybe I'm the only one who has issues with new OSX versions.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by jonknee on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:14PM (#4554637)
> I would think this would hurt their overall adoption rates (especially long term) as people get sick of constantly upgrading their OS and dealing with any fallout that results.

If by constantly you mean one time during the last five years, then yea that would be pretty annoying. The vast majority of people have moved onto a new computer or done at least one upgrade. Updates used to be more of a pain, now you just hit purchase and wait for a little bit.

If you haven't upgraded your computer in five years, you should be able to live with a browser than won't be upgraded anymore either. Apple requires 10.7.4 for Safari so you were abandoned by the Mother Ship a long time ago.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by dos1 on Friday September 21, 2012 @03:42PM (#4555382)
Well, the last time I used OSX for daily use, it was constantly pestering me to upgrade to various point releases. Those were usually massive downloads that required a reboot. Maybe things have changed?

Along that same vein, it seemed like every time I'd boot in to OSX - iTunes, iMovie, iPhoto et all would need 100+ MB updates to stay current.

I guess my experience on the upgrade treadmill (even staying on a major version of OSX) was very unpleasant.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by ryannielsen on Friday September 21, 2012 @03:57PM (#4555447)
Out of curiosity, what OS did you switch to that doesn't require regular, and often large, updates? I can't think of an OS I've ever used – various Linux distros, Windows, OS X, various BSDs, Solaris, and a smattering of random other unix variants – that didn't require some form of regular update that often required (or at least strongly suggested) a reboot. (Or the near equivalent of punting active users and relaunching a bunch of userland processes.)

Oh man, I remember my Gentoo days, where upgrading a single package would sometimes require new base libraries which in turn required a large chunk of the system to be rebuilt… definitely don't miss that process.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by jonknee on Friday September 21, 2012 @03:51PM (#4555421)
Apple is pretty bad at pushing binary updates, the file sizes for updates are as you mention, gigantic. But the update process is smooth, reboots are not required unless it's the system (iPhoto 9.4 came out today and there was no reboot, ditto for the latest Xcode from earlier in the week).

Most of the point upgrades for the system are security fixes. Every OS has a lot of them. Java has gotten a few security related updates this year too.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by batista on Friday September 21, 2012 @04:33PM (#4555610)
>Well, the last time I used OSX for daily use, it was constantly pestering me to upgrade to various point releases. Those were usually massive downloads that required a reboot. Maybe things have changed?

Constantly as in once every 3-4 months? Because that's the usual rate of point updates.

The alternative is what? Not having the latest stability and security fixes?

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by JackC on Friday September 21, 2012 @02:44PM (#4555106)
I would think this would hurt their overall adoption rates (especially long term) as people get sick of constantly upgrading their OS and dealing with any fallout that results.

Apple's willingness to obsolete their old tech has been the plan for a long time, and works fine for them and the higher-spending niche they're targeting. Basically the pitch (to oversimplify) is: we will make technical decisions based only on supporting the last two or three years of customers. If you keep up with us, things will work great for you, because we won't be slowing things down to maintain compatibility. If you have hardware or software older than that, good luck, but it's not our problem if our new stuff doesn't work for you. The only promise is that we won't compromise the product in order to save you money.[1]

This works for Apple (and the customers who keep upgrading) because it's nice to live in an ecosystem where you can assume modern hardware and software -- for example, where developers can reasonably target multitouch trackpads or webcams or motion-graphic APIs or whatever within a year or two after they're released, and cruft can be thrown out of the OS when it's no longer needed.

As it happens, I'm one of those customers -- I spend more than half my waking life on computers, and I don't mind spending a little more to work with modern hardware, and to have an OS that assumes I have modern hardware. I'm not trying to glorify or demonize that -- it's just a business model targeted at a certain part of the market that likes it that way, or at least accepts the downsides in exchange for the upsides.

[1] Please don't feel compelled on my account to recite all the ways Apple doesn't live up to this pitch. Believe me, I know. (Quicktime 7?) I still think it's a decent approximation.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by alanh on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:12PM (#4554620)
I love updating my Mac. Each new version makes it better, and problems seem to be minor and rare. It’s worlds different from the Windows upgrade <del>rat-race</del> <ins>process</ins>.

That said, yes, the hardware seems to have a shorter shelf-life than would be ideal. Your computer is, what, 2005 vintage? Seven years is too short, but still an old age in the world of technology, and longer than most competitors’ hardware lasts.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by pkamb on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:24PM (#4554689)
> Each new version makes it better

Since 10.6 that has definitely not been true.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by alanh on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:41PM (#4554780)
Thanks for the objective fact, dear sir.

While that may be true w.r.t. stability, the functionality, graphics, and polish have only gotten better. Security, too: consider FileVault 2. That’s what I like.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by sbuk on Friday September 21, 2012 @02:25PM (#4555006)
Depends on your POV. Personally, I like it. Anecdotally my cousin, independently of me I might add, has just bought an 13" MBA and he seems to think it's like a breath of fresh air. Horses for courses. But, yes, whatever you are using is the best.
Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by masklinn on Friday September 21, 2012 @02:37PM (#4555071)
Do you mean 10.7? Because 10.6 was everything 10.5 was, except better on pretty much every front.
Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by pkamb on Friday September 21, 2012 @02:44PM (#4555103)
Right, Snow Leopard was a great upgrade[1]. Lion was a major downgrade.

[1] Except for the abysmal changes to Exposé. Luckily there was a hack to get the Leopard version back: http://superuser.com/questions/118424/old-leopard-expose-on-...

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by danieldk on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:39PM (#4554771)
I love updating my Mac. Each new version makes it better, and problems seem to be minor and rare. It’s worlds different from the Windows upgrade rat-race.

Huh? I am hoping that my sarcasm radar didn't pick this up. But, most software still runs perfectly fine on Windows XP. In fact, all of our university's Windows computers still run Windows XP (with up to date Creative Suite, Office, SPSS, etc. versions). Since Windows XP was released in 2001 (!), that's eleven years and counting.

What rat race?

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by alanh on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:44PM (#4554793)
I mis-spoke. I didn’t mean “rat race.” I meant process. I am not saying there are too many Windows updates; I am saying you are far more likely to have problems after upgrading Windows than you are a Mac. For example, I literally cannot install Windows 7 on a laptop I acquired that shipped with Windows Vista. HP simply does not make the required drivers. It even seems the optical drive will not function correctly during a Win 7 installation attempt. It’s mind-blowingly sucktastic.

There are Macs too old for the latest OS X, yes, but they are pretty old, and were able to keep up-to-date for years.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by samspot on Friday September 21, 2012 @02:12PM (#4554933)
I bought an ibook in 2002 and each time an upgrade was announced I chose not to purchase the upgrade (none of the advertised features appealed to me). Eventually I was not able to run safari anymore which I have never forgiven them for. In my view Apple is charging users for service packs.
Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by masklinn on Friday September 21, 2012 @02:38PM (#4555079)
> Eventually I was not able to run safari

Of course you were, you were not able to update Safari anymore. And why would you be?

> In my view Apple is charging users for service packs.

Right, 10.0 to 10.8 is exactly the same OS, just 8 service packs, exactly... (you're joking right?)

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by samspot on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @07:07PM (#4578487)
I wasn't expecting so much hostility, but I'll answer the question. At the time I believe I was comparing 10.2 - 10.3 and I didn't see any value there. It is doubtful that I would still be on 10.2 after 10 years, but I didn't enjoy my time on mac so I never bought another one.
Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by sbuk on Friday September 21, 2012 @02:32PM (#4555041)
And what is wrong with that? Seriously. Who is to say that one business model is better than another? Jaguar to Tiger was a big leap, as was Panther to Leopard; certainly as big a leap as XP to Vista.
Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by batista on Friday September 21, 2012 @04:38PM (#4555642)
>I bought an ibook in 2002 and each time an upgrade was announced I chose not to purchase the upgrade (none of the advertised features appealed to me).

That's not how it works.

You either go on with the program or you get left behind.

>Eventually I was not able to run safari anymore which I have never forgiven them for.

You could run your old Safari just perfect. You just couldn't run the latest versions. Which you kind of caused on yourself.

Especially since the OS went to some major transitions to more modern technologies and APIs, which you opted out from.

>In my view Apple is charging users for service packs.

Sure, because the progress in any other OS has a much higher rate, and those features come for free...

(Not to mention that OS X versions cost 1/3 of what Windows versions costed, and now cost 1/8 of that, PLUS you can install the same bought version in multiple machines, so, more like 1/16 of Windows).

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by samspot on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @07:10PM (#4578495)
You need to look not at the cost of specific versions, but at the cost of staying current over a period of years. I haven't done the math on that.

With windows I always upgraded because I wanted the new OS. I've never felt compelled to get the newest windows in order to get something to work (In fact I've had the opposite experience -- upgrade windows only if you want something to break!).

>You could run your old Safari just perfect. You just couldn't run the latest versions. Which you kind of caused on yourself.

Yes, by refusing to pay the $80.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by batista on Friday September 21, 2012 @04:31PM (#4555593)
>Apple's incessant need to obsolete their old operating systems is surprising to me. I would think this would hurt their overall adoption rates (especially long term) as people get sick of constantly upgrading their OS and dealing with any fallout that results.

No, it helps getting technology ahead. Instead of, you know, having hundreds of millions of people still using Windows XP, as they do.

Plus, what "fallout"? Each release has some issues for some people in some use cases, but that is irrespective of some 5 year older release getting deprecated or not. And the issues --which don't affect all, usually just a small minority, e.g the Vagrant users as of late-- get ironed out eventually with point releases.

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by ionforce on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:11PM (#4554610)
Yes. You got it. You are the only one. Next.

Maybe Apple's "incessant need to obsolete" is part of their secret sauce. They're doing pretty well for themselves these days. Look at Microsoft, Captain "Never Break Anything". How are they doing?

Re:Chrome no longer supports Mac OS X 10.5 by RegEx on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:14PM (#4554628)
You're not clever, you're just rude.