Re:Google Maps' advantage over Apple Maps
by bmeckel on Friday September 21, 2012 @08:57AM
(#4553535)
I don't think that's their thinking actually. I think they knew it would be near impossible to have a product at launch be as impressive as googles and they're ok with that. However, by deploying in a mandatory setting with such a large user base they can catch up to Google quickly. Who knows though, they may have legitimately overlooked it.
Re:Google Maps' advantage over Apple Maps
by brudgers on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:04AM
(#4553546)
For years, Google has been sending fleets of specially equipped cars down countless roads in order to help verify their map data. It is impossible to imagine Apple undertaking such a massive and unsexy project as a first mover, nevermind as in an effort which would obviously be copying Google.
What has changed as Apple has scaled is that they are willing to weather a PR storm.
Re:Google Maps' advantage over Apple Maps
by bmeckel on Friday September 21, 2012 @10:40AM
(#4553915)
I don't think street view is what made google that much better than maps. It's the search that works, and detailed maps, which were around from before street view. But I do think you're partially right on the apple front, but they do stuff that pisses people off all the time, the difference is that it's usually taking out a feature (like Ethernet) that is only beginning to be phased out by the other tech companies. The big difference is that the maps change doesn't just bother geeks, but gets at their main user base, which they're usually pretty careful about.
Re:Google Maps' advantage over Apple Maps
by snogglethorpe on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:01PM
(#4556722)
> Nobody, including Google, consistently delivers functional map data to mobile devices every time
Sure, nobody's perfect. There's so much data that problems inevitably slip through.
But Google's maps are at least "good enough" in most important markets. Apple's are not. That is a problem.
Re:Google Maps' advantage over Apple Maps
by JoeAltmaier on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:18AM
(#4553594)
Navigation has become a platform feature; people buy their phones for the whole package. To find out a depended-upon assumed competency is missing is perceived as betrayal.
Imagine if it couldn't make calls, or got the wrong person when you did call? That would incite a similar emotional response.
Nobody, including Google, consistently delivers functional map data to mobile devices every time, at least not in the Atlanta metro area. I travel there with some frequency for various soccer tournaments as a referee or parent. It is not uncommon for one or another device to provide faulty routing to the people involved in a match. Sometimes it's Garmin. Sometimes it's Android. sometimes Bing.
People don't primarily buy smartphones for the maps any more than people primarily buy smartphones based on call quality. Apple knows this. Apple sells phones because of iTunes and brand positioning.
The issues with maps didn't even garner a comment among the Apple fans in yesterday's Facebook feed. The edge cases among iPhone users that will be lost over poor quality maps is more than offset by the Genius's sales pitch about how easy Apple's map application is to use.