Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by greendestiny on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:34AM
(#4553143)
Looks cool, can I ask where you sourced the historical data from?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by startuprob on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:36AM
(#4553149)
We're using Xignite's API right now. It's super-simple to integrate with.
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by gns24 on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:51AM
(#4553720)
That's useful to know. Is that daily data? Have you found it to be reliable? When I started testing moving-average based strategies, my blog post about it ended up being largely about data issues, from both Google and Yahoo finance: http://grahamstratton.org/straightornamental/entries/movinga...
An extreme example was an opening value off by a factor of 100 on one day.
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by mikecsh on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:04PM
(#4554288)
In my experience, even historical or realtime data from Reuters/Bloomberg/CQG can have serious errors such as that - every trading system should be sanity checking its market data!!
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by emilioolivares on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:23AM
(#4553610)
Super interesting! Could you shed some light on to how much you are spending on the data? Is it in the hundreds, thousands or ten-thousands? Is it feasible for one person to bootstrap a website with Xignite?
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by mikecsh on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:39AM
(#4553153)
Why did you choose that over something like Yahoo! Finance or Google?
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by Permit on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:15AM
(#4553583)
I've had a lot of problems with Yahoo not having complete historical data, especially on thinly traded or OTC stocks. I wouldn't recommend using their data in a production application.
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by afarquhar on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:44AM
(#4553164)
yeah that caught us out - we found that even though the data is freely available from those sources, you're not allowed to include that data in a commercial app :-(
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by mikecsh on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:53AM
(#4553191)
Oh really? That's interesting - does that apply even if it's not distributed with the commercial app? I'm sure I've used trading platforms before which use Yahoo...
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by afarquhar on Friday September 21, 2012 @07:06AM
(#4553218)
Our understanding of the Yahoo/google T&Cs was that we couldn't aim to profit from their data (http://finance.yahoo.com/badges/tos). We may be being overcautious but we didn't want to risk getting into trouble ;-)
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by greendestiny on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:50AM
(#4553182)
They look pretty awesome. I had some mobile app idea a while ago but commercial data rates are just too scary, good luck with this app!
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by pja on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:53AM
(#4553195)
How far back does it go?
Re:Show HN: Quantblocks - Backtest your trading strategies
by startuprob on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:56AM
(#4553197)
Xignite allows us to show the full historical data of an instrument, but because we're taking a lean approach at testing how people use it, we're limiting them to a few years.