News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pandora doesn't hash their passwords by mrb on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:16PM (#4552025)
The attribute name may be obfuscated, but it appears to be always the same (at least in my browsers): bc673ea54a2b7153aaafbf178e9b0892e1f2e56be5aaa5a7
Re:Pandora doesn't hash their passwords by cbsmith on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:18AM (#4552216)
It's a different attribute name on my system. Looks like it is different for each account, as it should be.

It's just sad seeing Pandora raked over the coals for this when they clearly have put in a lot of thought and done things as right as possible given their constraints.

Re:Pandora doesn't hash their passwords by mrb on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:30AM (#4552259)
I know why it is different on each system, it is because the numeric user ID is encoded in it.

I am 99% sure I am right, all the fields/values are merely obfuscated with a constant key. Not proper encryption at all.

Re:Pandora doesn't hash their passwords by cbsmith on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:41AM (#4552485)
> I know why it is different on each system, it is because the numeric user ID is encoded in it.

Yes, this is what I was saying.

> I am 99% sure I am right, all the fields/values are merely obfuscated with a constant key. Not proper encryption at all.

Okay, so if I tell you my key for the field is: bc673ea54a2b7153aaafbf178e9b0892e1f2e56be5aaa5a7, can you discern my key? I'm betting not.

First, this is indeed obfuscation. There undoubtedly is a constant key. The point is merely to make it difficult for an attacker to automate an attack with "grab the attribute with key X". It's possible these attributes are HMAC's of the attribute name + a randomly generated secret, which is actually a pretty good use of encryption under the circumstances. It's certainly miles beyond what most other sites use, and makes attacks against the HTML5 a waste of time (way better to go after the elements in the DOM, which have constant names).

Re:Pandora doesn't hash their passwords by stcredzero on Friday September 21, 2012 @11:11AM (#4554067)
> First, this is indeed obfuscation. There undoubtedly is a constant key...It's certainly miles beyond what most other sites use

The state of typical security in software projects of the 1990's: sad, sad... Any improvement in 2012: such a piddling little improvement. The trend is clear as is the conclusion: the average dev can't be trusted to do security. It doesn't work!

Re:Pandora doesn't hash their passwords by cbsmith on Friday September 21, 2012 @03:21PM (#4555281)
There isn't much more you can do with the key names really. The issue with them using a static key for encrypting the local password is another thing...
Re:Pandora doesn't hash their passwords by stcredzero on Friday September 21, 2012 @04:27PM (#4555568)
> The issue with them using a static key for encrypting the local password is another thing

Actually, it is the thing that I was referring to. Doing things with the key names is another thing -- wily and probably benefits them a little, but it isn't real security.

Re:Pandora doesn't hash their passwords by mrb on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:41AM (#4553156)
An attacker would just grab ALL keys, decrypt them, and look at those of the form Uxxxxxxx.Password.