News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by waterlesscloud on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:32PM (#4551319)
Hmm.

They needed to make some sort of move, but banning simulations and renderings (Really?) seems to be terrible overkill.

If anything, this move makes it much more a store. You can only put up products that exist. There's no funding of development.

Not sure this is a good solution on their part.

EDIT: Fully in support of the "Risks and Challenges" section. Makes it like an investment prospectus.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by guelo on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:45PM (#4551377)
The problems is skilled designers are starting to pull off big time scams fooling people for hundreds of thousands of dollars. People see realistic renderings of a hoverboard or whatever and they immediately open their wallets without realizing that their is very little chance that they will be able to pull it off. If people see a skateboard with some glued-on fans they will be much more skeptical.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by jonnathanson on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:06PM (#4551462)
Can we actually prove fraud in any of these cases, though? I'm not saying it can't happen, or that it hasn't happened. But we should never attribute to malice what can be more readily attributed to stupidity. I'm more inclined to believe that a bunch of people got in over their heads than that a bunch of people intentionally scammed backers.

I may be wrong. But can someone point to some concrete examples? Fraud is a pretty heavy charge to level against Kickstarter projects, and it's also an indirect accusation that Kickstarter is a hotbed of such activity.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by yummies on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:33PM (#4551552)
Wanting to prevent campaigns that will end in failure due to "stupidity", or even people who "got in over their heads" is just as valid as wanting to prevent fraud. Kickstarter's image/brand will be hurt by poorly executed campaigns that fail for whatever reason, so it's in their best interest to keep those to a minimum.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by jonnathanson on Friday September 21, 2012 @10:01AM (#4553751)
I don't disagree, but the cause of an unshipped product matters. If people believe Kickstarter campaigners are naive, that's one thing; they'll proceed with a bit more caution. If people believe that Kickstarter campaigners are intentionally trying to screw them over and run off with their money, that's another thing entirely. The former erodes trust in individual Kickstarter camaigners; the latter erodes fundamental trust in the site itself.

True, Kickstarter should be trying to address the issue, regardless of its cause. But let's be careful before leaping to the conclusion that people have been acting in bad faith.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by evilduck on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:28AM (#4552250)
I've thought for a while now that Kickstarter should have upper bounds for funding to prevent people from unwittingly accepting too much money and forcing the scale and scope of their project to change. Once a project is 200% funded, stop allowing more backers.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by regularfry on Friday September 21, 2012 @04:46AM (#4552888)
I had a similar thought, that rewards should only be granted while you're under the funding target. If you want to pile on later to make sure the project has the best chance it can? Fine, but no reward - that goes to the people who actually made it possible at all.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by bobds on Friday September 21, 2012 @07:21AM (#4553260)
You can limit the number of slots per reward, which is essentially the same.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by evilduck on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:38AM (#4553663)
Yes, but that doesn't stop people from adding more slots than they can realistically handle.

The skills, knowledge, and resources to produce 1k widgets is totally different than producing 1MM widgets. I might be able to brute-force manufacture 1k widgets from my garage and that would kickstart the business if that's my skill and scale estimate. I need staff, facilities and a different type of supplier if I need to make millions, and I may not have what it takes to deliver on that.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by 001sky on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:18PM (#4551510)
People suggesting something unethical need be illegal are part of the issue. In the USA there is a tradition of aggressive play within the rules. If we want to bend the rules [1] a bit -- and make no mistake, that is kickstarter and crowd-sourcing -- there needs to be some ethical nous in place. Both by the companies and the supporters.

[1] The reason US required QUIbs and the SEC and the related regulatory structure (re: financial investment contracts) is precisely to create such bright line playing fields. But these lines are sufficiently complex to require a "price of admission".

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by TeMPOraL on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:30AM (#4552461)
> But we should never attribute to malice what can be more readily attributed to stupidity.

I don't know. On the other hand, if you leave a loophole in a system, it will be exploited; that's a basic human law. So in this case I'd guess both scenarios occur - there are so many assholepreneurs out there trying to find a way to "creatively" earn money that I wouldn't be surprised if those design scams were occuring more and more often.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by MatthewPhillips on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:10PM (#4551476)
Fraud is too strong of a word. However, unrealistic renders are at least dishonest, and even if not maliciously so, the effects are much the same.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by corin_ on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:37PM (#4551566)
Misleading rather than dishonest, dishonest implies intent, even if not malicious intent.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by saraid216 on Friday September 21, 2012 @05:54AM (#4553063)
Yeah, this seems to be something of a gray area. Not quite fraud, but heading very pointedly in that direction. Perhaps someone more familiar with relevant law knows of a term? Or maybe we should start thinking about inventing one.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by adgar on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:13PM (#4551486)
> Can we actually prove fraud in any of these cases, though?

Is this the standard we want?

If you used an investment service which said "we require proof beyond all reasonable doubt of criminal endeavors before taking down [some UGC]," how much would you trust those investments? What if the standard for takedowns was a bit higher?

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by Kerrick on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:46PM (#4551586)
> Is this the standard we want?

I'd say so, yes. Ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innocent_until_proven_guilty

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by jeremyjh on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:29PM (#4551906)
The question is not, did X commit fraud. The question is, "can fraudsters abuse the system maliciously?", and "can incompetents unintentionally abuse it?".

Since the answer is clearly "yes" - then taking some steps to reduce the impact of these vulnerabilities seem reasonable. If you are selling a product, show us the product. If you do not have a product, we want to be sure the backers know this.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by adgar on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:48PM (#4551599)
> I'd say so, yes.

Proof beyond all reasonable doubt is a lovely standard for a criminal justice system. Note that it is not used in civil suits in America - only criminal cases.

We're not talking about taking away people's freedom here. We're talking about an investment website.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by TillE on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:00PM (#4551642)
Some level of proof is still necessary, though. Not just an accusation.

In general with Kickstarter failures current and future, I think we'll find the evidence weighs heavily in favor of incompetence rather than malice. There's no shortage in the world of business ventures that are honest to goodness failures.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by adgar on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:44PM (#4551788)
> Some level of proof is still necessary, though. Not just an accusation.

Is anyone arguing that mere accusations should result in kickstarter takedowns? You make a good point... just a sort of obvious one.

This is clearly a hard problem, and neither extreme of "proof beyond reasonable doubt" or "accusation = takedown" works. Maybe that's why this space is so unexplored! That doesn't absolve Kickstarter from having to discover the palatable middle ground.

Hard work is hard, and I think today's announcements are part of that hard work. So I say: keep it up, Kickstarter!

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by anthonyb on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:55PM (#4551819)
> Is anyone arguing that mere accusations should result in kickstarter takedowns?

Yes, it should - if it's backed by a legal letter, Kickstarter might be liable too, if the suit is sucessful.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by adgar on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:10PM (#4552012)
You seem to have misunderstood "mere accusations."

Takedowns due to "mere accusations" to me means that I can fire off an e-mail if I see a kickstarter project that looks sketchy and have it taken down post-haste.

To me, that is highly suboptimal.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by anthonyb on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:17AM (#4552431)
Well if it's based on this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4549792 then Kickstarter should take it down. It's a civil matter, so there's no "beyond reasonable doubt" required, and if Kickstarter are helping fund infringement, then they're on the hook too.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by alanctgardner2 on Friday September 21, 2012 @10:47AM (#4553957)
Is there actually a legal basis for this? As in, if Stripe was, in good faith, processing payments for a company which is selling (allegedly) infringing products, they're obligated to stop processing payments immediately? It seems like there'd be a clause in the TOS to indemnify them.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by makomk on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:11PM (#4556742)
They didn't just take it down - they left no way for anyone to find out what had happened to the project by looking at the Kickstarter site. There's just a page saying the project doesn't exist anymore for some unspecified reason.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by Angostura on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:31PM (#4551549)
A pragmatic approach would be to enforce the inclusion of a 'This is only a rendered mock-up' -type standard badges on the images.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by AJ007 on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:15PM (#4551695)
Do you have links for Kickstarter projects you think are outright scams?
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by makomk on Friday September 21, 2012 @07:49PM (#4556519)
The famous example of a highly-funded hardware project that's almost certainly a scam is ZionEyez: http://www.forbes.com/sites/markgibbs/2012/08/20/the-truth-a...
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by neilk on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:38PM (#4551771)
A game called 'Mythic' is a notorious example.

http://betabeat.com/2012/04/this-is-what-a-kickstarter-scam-...

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by flyinRyan on Friday September 21, 2012 @08:50AM (#4553513)
I would consider this a poor example. This idiot threw away his career for $4k (which he didn't even get?).
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by sharkweek on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:57PM (#4551430)
I asked this a while back and the answer was pretty much "no" -- but I'm curious if that's changed. Have there recently been any high profile examples of fraud through crowdfunding sites?
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by siganakis on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:46PM (#4551383)
There is a world of difference between a physical working prototype and product that you can deliver in commercial quantities.

I guess Kickstarter is aiming to fund physical projects that already have a working prototype and require funding to deliver in large quantities.

It seems fair to me, as the person requesting funding should be required to have put in a fair amount of effort beyond a flashy 3 minute video promising the world. A working prototype seems to be a fair bar.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by ghshephard on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:49PM (#4551394)
I think that Kickstarter is happiest with the things like ElevationDock - a fully functional prototype, that they just had to figure out how to manufacture in large quantities.

They certainly had their challenges - but would have had no chance without a big group of people ordering up front.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by samspot on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:59PM (#4551438)
I don't think it says anywhere that the prototype has to work. I'm reading this in a way that says I have to show what I've already accomplished. It is ok if the prototype doesn't work yet, and I think it is ok to expect the project creators to do some of the work before they create a kickstarter project.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by shasta on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:17PM (#4551506)
This is a prototype of my perpetual motion machine. The batteries will not be required in the production version.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by tesseract on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:57PM (#4551633)
That's kind of the point. The fact that you have to show the prototype allows potential backers to make a judgement about whether they think you are likely to succeed or not.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by robomartin on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:01AM (#4552388)
I think they are right in being careful. It's about time.

I use Solidworks for mechanical design and Modo for photorealistic rendering. I assure you that, with enough skill and effort, one can make photorealistic renderings that, to the uninformed, look like the product is ready to go and that the funding is a mere formality. No, Kickstarter did the right thing here.

That said, I am hoping that they will allow 3D renderings and animations as added illustrations if and ONLY if one shows actual realized versions of the proposed hardware in the project. The reason I say this is that 3D renderings and animations are extremely useful tools for the communication of function and some ideas that might be hard or impossible to convey using actual hardware. A good example is a cross-sectional cut showing moving parts.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by ghshephard on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:47PM (#4551389)
The problem with Renderings/simulations is that people believe that things like: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/limemouse/lifx-the-light... actually exist, when they are just concepts right now.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by mcphilip on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:19PM (#4551516)
Cynically, I wonder if this policy change was not prompted by Kickstarter's own doubts about the lifx team being able to deliver. After all, this is the same team that couldn't meet demand for their custom cardboard box project.

I wonder if in the future there will be a requirement to limit the number of backers on every project. Logically there seems to be a point where additional money from backers over what was asked for leads to difficulty delivering at all.

For instance, say I could make 10 custom widgets a month at $100 a piece. I might decide to launch a Kickstarter project asking for $1200 to gauge if at least 10 other people are interested in my fancy innovative widget. What happens if I end up raising $12000? My target of 20% profit on each widget is no longer possible unless the backers are willing to wait up to 10 months for me to deliver. The only other option is to invest money into producing widgets in larger volume to meet this initial demand. That investment would only make sense if there were some reasonable expectation that demand would stay at the same level after the Kickstarter project ended.

So back to my original cynicism, maybe Kickstarter sees signs that some very good marketers are having enormous success with Kickstarter projects whilst being in completely over their heads...

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by ghshephard on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:22PM (#4551522)
Your suggestion that there be a "limit to the number of backers on a project" would have probably saved the elevation dock guys some grief. On the other hand, I want the Planetary Annihilation guys (Digital Product) to have HUGE oversubscription - we got funding for Metal Worlds, Water Worlds, Galactic War, and an Orchestra Score through extra funding!
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by johnpmayer on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:11PM (#4551684)
Worth mentioning that the major content of the Planetary Annihilation page was their simulation/rendering - completely concept-art.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by haldean on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:55PM (#4551818)
It's not a hardware project so the new rules don't apply.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by ghshephard on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:56PM (#4551821)
Well - the major content (in my mind) was Jon Mavor/Steve Thompson.

If all they do is port some small portion of Planetary Annihilation forward, then I'll be happy.

If they actually deliver on 50% of what they've promised + Orchestral Score - I'll be beyond happy.

I spent a good portion of 1997/1998 playing Total Annihilation.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by omni on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:47PM (#4551590)
Good point. This restriction should only apply to products with a marginal cost to produce / ship / what have you.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by Evbn on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:09PM (#4551862)
They could easily set up a bullpen of 5 projects to soak up extra funding. It is completely pointless to fund a project over its budget. The project can change its budget and plan/promise of they want to raise more.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by ghshephard on Thursday September 20, 2012 @10:40PM (#4551940)
I think the extra $200K was well worth the Orchestral Score. I'm happy they got overfunded.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by voodoomagicman on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:23AM (#4552232)
I think you have a good point, but wanted to point out that you already can restrict the number of rewards available when starting a project.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by Tsagadai on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:47PM (#4551593)
Something must be done or their (kickstarter's) business may collapse. Banning renderings will probably cut down a bit on expectations not matching delivery, which presently is a problem. Quite a few projects seem to have underestimated the difficulties of quality control and mass production.

However, it is still pretty easy to get a nice milled or extruded aluminium block and call it a prototype so I don't think it will completely eliminate unscrupulous frauds.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by AJ007 on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:19PM (#4551708)
Yeah but that "prototype" may not look nearly as amazing as a flashy 3D animation.

Is what kickstarter asking that unreasonable? (other than their lawyers probably told them do this now or suffer consequences that could mean no more business.) If someone can't produce a physical prototype of an item, do they really deserve hundreds of thousands or a million dollars?

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by nettdata on Thursday September 20, 2012 @07:39PM (#4551346)
I agree. I think a good compromise would be to ensure that anything that was a simulation or rendering was very obviously labeled as such, so that there would be absolutely no doubt in the viewer's mind.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by Lerc on Thursday September 20, 2012 @08:23PM (#4551530)
I agree that they needed to do something. That something is totally not this. This feels like they want to do whatever is the least amount of work.

Kickstarter is supposed to be a service, for a share of the income they are supposed to facilitate the connection between creators and audience. Rubber stamping an increasingly bureaucratic set of rules is not the way to do this.

A better solution would have been to add the ability for prospective supporters to voice queries and concerns where they could be seen prominently on the page. Right now it seems the creators receive questions and pick the ones they want to answer and place an update answering the questions.

Even better would be to have Kickstarter assess the creators claims on their ability to deliver and assess queries raised by prospective supporters. That would be a real service offering real value, it would also cost real money. Right now Kickstarter's revenue comes from the fact that Kickstarter is popular. The thing that makes creators choose Kickstarter over another platform is almost entirely due to prominence. That cannot be sustained. Eventually it will have to rest on quality of service. The current set of changes do not increase the quality of service.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by SoftwareMaven on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:00PM (#4551645)
Even better would be to have Kickstarter assess the creators claims on their ability to deliver and assess queries raised by prospective supporters.

I can't imagine that will ever happen. If they vetted projects or teams, it would probably put some liability on their shoulders. They are going to do everything they can to prevent that.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by lambda on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:11AM (#4552190)
> You can only put up products that exist.

That's not true. You can demonstrate prototypes. What you can't do is just whip something up in Blender, do a nice rendering, and then start selling it with with the rewards being "1 widget, 2 widgets, 5 widgets, 10 widgets, 20 widgets", with no indication that you've actually done your homework to say if this is even possible.

They want people to actually have some sort of prototype, something to show for their work, rather than just a slick graphical presentation and reward system that implies that it's far closer to completion than it actually is.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by mtgx on Friday September 21, 2012 @06:56AM (#4553198)
I tend to agree with you. They just need to stop the project guys asking for "pre-order" types of donations. Or make them not send the product to the backers for that they're paying.

It should be 100% clear that it's just a donation, whether it's $10, $100 or $1000. But you're not getting any product for that donation, until the product launches, when you can go and buy it.

Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by andrewflnr on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:31PM (#4552059)
If the problem is that people who see realistic renderings feel that the product already exists, a hand-drawn (but still accurate) rendering would allow people to see that the owner sort of knows what they're doing without getting their hopes up. Maybe the same would apply to detailed plans, or other obviously-not-the-product visual design documentation.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by ja2ke on Friday September 21, 2012 @02:41PM (#4555090)
I think we're just going to see a rise in more "architectural" styled development renderings, over fully polished marketing-style imagery. I welcome that.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by frankdenbow on Thursday September 20, 2012 @09:41PM (#4551778)
Its only for product design and hardware projects, which seems reasonable for physical items.
Re:Kickstarter is Not a Store by diminoten on Friday September 21, 2012 @10:52AM (#4553981)
Use your words instead of a cool Photoshop to describe what you intend on making.