Also, things like TPMs, Secure Boot, etc, are good security tools which can be used by an end user to get security guarantees over their device.
I use Secure Boot with Linux because, when done right, it means you can get full disk encryption without gaps (at best, without secure boot, you have an un-encrypted bootloader on a flash drive which decrypts your disk and boots your machine, and this is a clunky setup).
I use GrapheneOS's hardware attestation to alert me if something compromises my android phone's operating system.
Now it's true that these features are abused by companies like Google to force you to run a blessed Android build if you want to use e.g. Google Pay (which is the only mobile payment option in e.g. the UK). But it's important to separate the technology from the bad actors abusing it.
Curious to hear if there are any unintended consequences to this that I may not have thought of. Think of this as a strawman proposal.
Is this legal ownership or technical 0wnership?
Part of the hardware:
- Can be restricted to specific devices
- Must be available under GPLv3, including anti-tivoization provisions (forced bootloader unlock)
- May not attempt to use TPMs, DRM, or other systems to support assertions about client devices
Not part of the hardware:
- May only interact with hardware through public, documented, APIs in the "part of hardware" category
- Using alternatives from competitors must be fully supported
- When made by a company that also makes hardware, must also work on competitors' hardware (at least one, more if technically feasible)
- May be under a proprietary license
- Must not attempt to assert anything regarding the hardware, so things like Google Safteynet are now illegal. Security boundary must be shifted to consider client devices insecure
This is, I think, a good compromise to allow software developers to get paid without taking away ownership of hardware devices. Developers can be paid for "part of the hardware" software with money from selling the hardware, and "not part of the hardware" software can be trivially commercialized under a proprietary license. But, there is no way for a user to end up unable to control their hardware, or incentivized to configure it in a specific way.