News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by Atlas667 on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @11:54AM (#45504734)
Most of this system was created when half of us were slaves, the other half were poor illiterate farmers, and only a tiny fraction could read, write and rule.

There is no democracy. There has always been "democracy" for the bourgeoise, not for the majority. Only for those who control production.

And what has been put into place since then can easily be manipulated by the rich.

How do you think we got here?

There are no real mechanisms for mass democracy.

Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by goku12 on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @12:06PM (#45504929)
Is this about Canada or the US? Either way, you can either defend and demand for the democracy, or give up and stop claiming democracy altogether. This is a problem with democracies everywhere. I don't know about you, but I'm not too enthusiastic about a future that resembles the dark ages.
Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by Atlas667 on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @05:18PM (#45509009)
This applies to either.

The democracy we need threatens those in power.

What say does the average poor person in your town have? To endorse someone they cant control? To choose from amongst the few candidates that the big interests have developed and then cross their fingers??

Letting individuals control production creates a divided society, one of workers and one of owners.

Where one has unequal leverage over the other but are supposed to (on paper) exist on the same democratic level.

Mom and pop shops may come your mind, or someone who owns a franchise or small business, the truth is that even small business owners are nearly wholly beholden to large capital and huge finance capital.

What say does a walmart employee have compared to the owners of walmart?

While you were learning about what the hell the electoral college is, some others were being trained on how to lobby effectively.

Mass democracy threatens the status quo almost entirely.

There does not exist a party for the people. And if it were to exist it would be outlawed and threatened like they have been in the past.

Would you suppress a peoples party if you had billions on the line?

Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by SoftTalker on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @05:23PM (#45509059)
Anyway, the USA is a representative republic.
Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by Atlas667 on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @05:40PM (#45509256)
Exactly. We are designed so that those with more power can play their games in DC and through out all the public offices in these states.

There is a reason why labor movements have been nearly completely wiped out from collective history.

Those who don't take this govts anti-socialist stance seriously must realize that the history of modern warfare and the history of anti-socialism share way too much space.

Mass democracy is a threat to the status quo.

Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by lisbbb on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @05:37PM (#45509225)
You can't look at California, New York, New Jersey, Maryland, Illinois, Oregon, Washington, Massachusetts--states who have these very long-term Democrat majorities, and tell me we have a representative anything! Those places will likely never turn back to any kind of balanced representative rule. They pass whatever the hell they want and the only pushback is through our Federal courts who often take years to produce meager relief.

It's not "getting bad" it "is bad."

Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by nbngeorcjhe on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @08:25PM (#45510617)
[flagged]
Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by tomhow on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @11:58PM (#45511913)
> wtf are you talking about?

Please dont' comment like this on HN. The guidelines ask us to be kind and constructive when engaging in discussions here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by kimixa on Wednesday October 08, 2025 @01:33AM (#45512428)
It's also a failure state of real discussion to discount someone's voice simply because of perceived incivility.

Or conversely, weigh someone's opinion higher simply because of phrasing rather than content.

Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by tomhow on Wednesday October 08, 2025 @01:44AM (#45512488)
The guidelines have been in place since soon after HN started, and have always been clear that kindness and curious conversation are what we're aiming for here.

In the case of this comment "wtf are you talking about?" may be at the milder end of the spectrum of abuse, "moron" certainly isn't.

Re:Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified... by kimixa on Wednesday October 08, 2025 @01:48AM (#45512518)
No, a representative democracy allows the majority to choose their representatives. And the majority chose one party in those states. That is what democracy is.

What you're asking for is rule by minority. At an extreme, an autocracy.