I must not have understood the article correctly because I took ChatGPT to be a stand in for LLM technology in general. But I think I am wrong.
That's how I meant it.
Right, and so I interpreted your comment
> I'm not sure I see how this is meaningfully different than the threat posed by a search engine.
as being about the world pre-LLMs and post-LLMs, not about Google in 2025 vs ChatGPT in 2025.
For the latter comparison, I agree, and in fact Google probably has an even richer history of people over time.
But like any “X is just Y” explanation, the former comparison fails to address the emergent effects of Y becoming faster/cheaper/better.
Its just another version of the classic computing problem "computers might not make a new thing possible, but it makes it possible to do an old thing at a scale that fundamentally changes the way it works"
This is the same as universal surveillance... sure, anyone could have followed you in public and watched where you are going, but if you record everything, now you can do it for everyone at any time. That changes how it works.