News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists are discovering a powerful new way to prevent ... by jszymborski on Saturday October 04, 2025 @01:26PM (#45474993)
Part of the reason cancer is such an interesting field of study in my personal opinion is:

(1) You get a lot of these chicken-or-egg situations where the answer is more like "chicken-AND-egg".

(2) Cancer is almost always the result of a million things going wrong at once... it's a slow unravelling of the bonkers number of safe-guards our cells have to keep them healthy and normal.

Inflammation is a normal part of a healthy, functioning body. It can be caused by anything from scraping your knee to getting a cold. It's useful, and as your comment says, it is an important part to fighting off infections which themselves in rare cases cause cancer. It also plays a pathological role in some diseased like auto-immune disorders, IBS, meningitis, etc...

Inflammation, both the healthy and pathological sort, can help set the stage for tumour to form by contributing to the formation of what's known as a "tumour microenvironment" [0]. Chronic inflammation, often caused by disease, is more likely to keep up this permissive environment than one-off cases, and therefore more likely to result in a tumour

By the way, we understand DNA mutation/damage to work similarly. It happens all the time naturally, and sometimes mutations are fortuitous, but mostly they are ironed out by the cells machinery. Increasing the rate of mutation can overwhelm that machinery and cause tumours to snowball.

So, that's how inflammation can contribute to the initialization of tumours or at least environments that are more permissive of tumours. Tumours, however, also might cause inflammatory response to promote cancer progression through hijacking cell signalling, promoting epithelial-mesenchymal transitions, etc... [1].

We've known inflammation has been linked to cancer since at least 1863 [2], so this is pretty well-trodden territory. The immune system and inflammation is extremely complicated (or at least, I always found it to be), so I'm also not surprised that there are a lot of mysteries lurking.

Finally, to answer your question: I'm sure in some cases inflammation is just bystander. My understanding is that inflammation is not the primary mechanism by which HPV causes cancer, so it is very easy to believe it to be a bystander in that case. H. pylori is a good example of chronic GI inflammation that raises your risk of cancer by way of inflammation. I'm not familiar with the fungal DNA research, so can't comment.

Also disclaimer: It's been a while since I've studied cancer directly, I'm more of a computational biologist these days. Sorry if I made an error here.

[0] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6831096/

[1] https://blog.cellsignal.com/hallmarks-of-cancer-tumor-promot...

[2] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

Re:Scientists are discovering a powerful new way to prevent ... by jongjong on Saturday October 04, 2025 @07:21PM (#45477628)
As a software engineer, I'm constantly exposed to system complexity. My experience is that even systems which seem relatively simple from the outside can be extremely complex. Beyond a certain level of complexity, it becomes very difficult to change something without breaking something else. You need to be aware of dependencies when making changes. It appears that the human body is a much more complex system than any software system, with much more complex interdependencies... Given this, it's not surprising at all that it's so difficult to develop solutions to problems like cancer. The whac-a-mole effect must be massive. Seems like every change has countless unintended side effects.
Re:Scientists are discovering a powerful new way to prevent ... by dboreham on Saturday October 04, 2025 @09:36PM (#45478198)
It has built-in error correction but sometimes there are more bits flipped than the correction codes can correct.
Re:Scientists are discovering a powerful new way to prevent ... by jszymborski on Saturday October 04, 2025 @10:26PM (#45478416)
Yah that's exactly it. The field of Systems Biology frames things very much in this way https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systems_biology#
Re:Scientists are discovering a powerful new way to prevent ... by srean on Sunday October 05, 2025 @05:09AM (#45480115)
A portion of the complexity comes from fixing bugs not at its root-cause. Once you have accumulated many such proximate fixes it becomes quite expensive to fix the bug at the root-cause level. The resident root-cause bug continues to create new problems downstream.

Not much different from biological evolution.

Re:Scientists are discovering a powerful new way to prevent ... by jongjong on Saturday October 11, 2025 @07:11PM (#45553544)
Great point. I chuckle at the fact that 'addressing the root cause' is what naturopaths and 'holistic medicine' practitioners are selling themselves on... Claiming that modern medicine is focused on selling drugs to mask symptoms and doesn't address the root cause... Though their solutions are often even more superficial on average... Besides maybe their approach vitamin deficiencies and supplements.