Re:Digital ID – The New Chains of Capitalist Surveillance
by buildfocus on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:45AM
(#45460585)
For Spain at least, most banks have foreigner accounts you can open with a passport, and convert into a normal account once you have local id later. It's a mildly unusual setup (and a bit confusing when you're new) but it's pretty widely available and it's not a significant blocker. There's plenty of other challenges and structural disadvantages as an immigrant, but this one at least isn't too bad.
If anything, there's really a big advantage to it for the banks - most locals already have banking, immigrants are the one market where you can get new customers without having to push them past the effort/laziness of switching from their existing setup.
Re:Digital ID – The New Chains of Capitalist Surveillance
by mytailorisrich on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:59AM
(#45460676)
It is not a problem to open a bank account with a foreign passport in the UK, and most banks have accounts for those who've just moved to the UK. Hundreds of thousands of people move to the UK every year...
Re:Digital ID – The New Chains of Capitalist Surveillance
by scott_w on Friday October 03, 2025 @05:08AM
(#45460750)
However, you also need proof of address to open a bank account. Which someone moving to the UK won’t have yet. This limits their options of bank accounts.
Re:Digital ID – The New Chains of Capitalist Surveillance
by mytailorisrich on Friday October 03, 2025 @05:18AM
(#45460812)
Which has no relation to Digital IDs whatsoever... and again most banks have accounts that cater for this situation.
Re:Digital ID – The New Chains of Capitalist Surveillance
by scott_w on Friday October 03, 2025 @05:57AM
(#45461068)
Allow me to repeat myself:
> This limits their options of bank accounts.
Now this:
> Which has no relation to Digital IDs whatsoever
Other countries use their ID systems for exactly this purpose, so I don't see how this has "no relation."
Re:Digital ID – The New Chains of Capitalist Surveillance
by scott_w on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:43AM
(#45460574)
Absolutely, it’s a major problem. I would think this system needs to hand out ID cards to everyone who needs one (student, work visa, alongside NI number, etc.) to break that loop.
Re:Digital ID – The New Chains of Capitalist Surveillance
by pjc50 on Friday October 03, 2025 @04:49AM
(#45460607)
For a while the UK had the stupid situation where there was a high-security biometric identity system, but only for immigrants, and one of the things you did as part of the process of becoming a citizen was the requirement to hand back or destroy the ID.
(this of course tells us where all the ID pressure is coming from: voters want an identity system that can be weaponized against immigrants and The Other.)
Lots of countries have this circularity, including Continental ones with ID systems, and I think it's an intentional anti-immigrant measure.