News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 02, 2025 @08:31PM (#45457296)
> hardly in the way that could be described as the destruction of the state

It would be a destruction of the nation-state of Israel as a state for the Israeli, predeominantly Jewish, nation.

> Abolishing Jim Crow in the south hardly destroyed the south

It certainly felt that way to them! Strongly enough that they fought a war over it. (EDIT: Nobody went to war over Jim Crow. They did over slavery. Jim Crow was basically an attempt to regain part of what was lost in the war. Put another way, even a war--alone--is not enough.)

That's the point. The single-state solution, practically, would require a war. I know we pulled out of Afghanistan. But I thought we'd have a bigger gap before another group of Westerners decided they like drawing borders in the Middle East, and that anyone who disagrees with them--including the people on the ground--should be violently forced to comply.

Re: by monocasa on Thursday October 02, 2025 @08:38PM (#45457361)
> It would be a destruction of the nation of Israel as the people of Israel see it.

Just like the people in my home states of Georgia, Florida, and Tennessee thought that ending Jim Crow would destroy them. They were wrong, just as the people of Israel would be wrong.

> It certainly felt that way to them! Strongly enough that they fought a war over it.

No war was fought over the end of Jim Crow.

> That's the point. The single-state solution, practically, would require a war. I know we pulled out of Afghanistan.

At the moment, probably. That can change.

> But I thought we'd have a bigger gap before another group of Westerners decided they like drawing borders in the Middle East, and that anyone who disagrees with them--including the people on the ground--should be violently forced to comply.

Those Knesset members are not asking western intervention to end their ethnostate.

Re: by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 02, 2025 @08:44PM (#45457404)
> They were wrong, just as the people of Israel would be wrong.

They may be. Maybe India and Pakistan could peacefully reünify, too. I'm doubtful. But that matters less than the people there being very much more doubtful.

> No war was fought over the end of Jim Crow

Sorry, fair enough. Ending Jim Crow wasn't a credible threat to the South at that time. The war had already been fought.

> At the moment, probably. That can change

Sure. But sentiment has to shift before one can peacefully move borders.

> Those Knesset members are not asking western intervention to end their ethnostate

I've lost your argument. (Also, ethnostate and nation-state are practically synonymous.)

Re: by dotancohen on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:35AM (#45460125)

  > Just like the people in my home states of Georgia, Florida, and Tennessee thought that ending Jim Crow would destroy them. They were wrong, just as the people of Israel would be wrong.
A better comparison might be Lebanon, or Bethleham. Lebanon was Christian majority in 1970, but the Christians cannot breed fast enough to compete with the Sunnis and Shias. But the Christians don't say that so clearly - the Druze (who were always a minority) say that is why the Shias are taking over. And all Western-valued Christians are exedousing out of Lebanon. I don't know where you live, but if you have Christian Lebanese nearby ask them what they think about a one-state solution with Muslims.

Just outside Rahat, a few years ago a car ran a red light and a bus hit it. The driver lived, but his three passengers were killed. That resulted in six widows and 48 orphans. We would be overwhelmed by population warfare in a generation.

Bethleham, too, was 80% Christian around 2000, when it went from Israeli civil control to PA civil control. Now it's less than 20% Christian. In a single generation.

Re: by 8note on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:31PM (#45466847)
The war for a single state is already happening mind you, and westerners are already involved and influential in it. i disagree that there is now an option to decide now that we dont want to draw borders, only whether we're satisfied with the new borders or not.