News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Signal's New PQ Ratchet by tptacek on Thursday October 02, 2025 @03:10PM (#45454025)
Part of the premise of FS/PCS is that "shit happens" to compromise keys even if the underlying cryptography is strong, so if you want a coherent end-to-end FS/PCS story, the claim would be that you need to be ratcheting everywhere.
Re:Signal's New PQ Ratchet by ragona on Thursday October 02, 2025 @03:16PM (#45454114)
Definitely, but when we're running around sprinkling PQ algorithms all over the place, it's on top of the asymmetric bits, not replacing the "boring" stuff like your symmetrically encrypted backups. Shit certainly does happen, especially where key management is involved, but I'm not sure I agree that offering an encrypted backup feature is necessarily undoing the FS/PCS story.

edit: Well, let me argue with myself for a moment. I don't think offering an encrypted backup feature undoes the PQ story. But FS/PCS is weakened, sure, since we're talking about all types of shit happening, not just currently known (or strongly theorized) attacks.

Re:Signal's New PQ Ratchet by tptacek on Thursday October 02, 2025 @03:20PM (#45454172)
I think they point they're making doesn't have much to do with PQ.
Re:Signal's New PQ Ratchet by elvisloops on Thursday October 02, 2025 @05:06PM (#45455566)
Yes, if Signal has effectively removed ratcheting and forward secrecy from the logical "encryption protocol" by encrypting all messages (even disappearing messages) with a single static key that never changes for your lifetime and sending them to the cloud, then all this talk about "post-quantum ratchets" is theater. There are no ratchets.
Re:Signal's New PQ Ratchet by tptacek on Thursday October 02, 2025 @05:10PM (#45455602)
I think it's a valid point but also that it assumes a lot about the threat model that can be disputed, so your "theater" point is not well taken.