News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by jahsome on Thursday October 02, 2025 @01:50PM (#45452986)
I'm genuinely curious what you'd define "nearby" and "well clear" as in concrete numbers.

For the sake of clarity: I am not arguing against your point, nor am I defending Amazon or the tech in any way shape or form.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by burkaman on Thursday October 02, 2025 @02:00PM (#45453144)
A human operator would see a moving crane and say "that's a construction site, I'm going to go around". They would not fly directly under a crane even if it visually looked clear. In this case the crane was actively lowering something, so the drone not only missed the cable but it flew directly in between the crane and a visible object hanging in the air below the crane.

For concrete numbers, I would say stay 50 yards away from construction equipment, and always laterally or above, not below. Honestly these drones are enormous so I think "don't go under" can just be a blanket rule. They can't be going under trees or bridges or overpasses either, they're too big.

Edit: Also, the drones themselves should be far enough apart that if one crashes the other has time to react and stop or change course. I don't have a concrete number there, it depends on their speed and acceleration, but they shouldn't be flying so close that if one crashes they all will.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by appreciatorBus on Thursday October 02, 2025 @02:08PM (#45453238)
In non-drone aviation, we require vehicles to be separated from each other by 5 nautical miles horizontally and 2,000 feet vertically. Additionally every area of the planet they fly over has an MSA figure - Minimum Safe Altitude - which is supposed to guarantee 1000 feet clearance over any obstacles or terrain.

Both of these allow healthy margins of error, whether that error is from a human pilot or ATC, or from computer systems - either in the vehicle or the ground.

I'd argue these would be a great place to start for drone aviation.

If such limits make drone burrito or toilet paper delivery expensive, that seems fine.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by wat10000 on Thursday October 02, 2025 @04:05PM (#45454839)
At least in the US, minimum separation is for when you're talking to air traffic control, and MSA is for flying on instruments. Minimum separation when you can see outside and aren't talking to ATC is "don't hit other planes." Minimum altitude is 500ft, or 1000ft over "congested areas," plus 500ft distance from any obstacle. Unless you're flying a helicopter (or powered parachute or hang glider) in which case the only requirement is "the operation is conducted without hazard to persons or property on the surface."

It would make sense for a quadcopter to follow helicopter rules. Obviously it does not follow the "without hazard" requirement if you crash into cables, though.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by appreciatorBus on Thursday October 02, 2025 @04:47PM (#45455353)
Fair enough, I am not a pilot, just a nerd so I wasn’t aware of this!

I’d agree the helicopter rules seem most appropriate, though I guess I’d still feel like that would still rule out operating anywhere near a building under construction.

That said, a regular helicopter that suffers a loss of power or other fault, still has options like autorotation to at least attempt a landing without killing anyone on the ground. Do drones have any equivalent ? I.e. if battery is below x% it returns to safe landing spot?

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by wat10000 on Thursday October 02, 2025 @04:52PM (#45455402)
"Without hazard" is pretty subjective, but I agree that it probably shouldn't include casually flying around cranes.

I don't know how drones are programmed, but landing immediately if the battery gets low certainly sounds like a sensible precaution. Electric motors might be reliable enough that you don't have to worry about gracefully handling failure of those. I hope so, because I don't think a quadcopter has much hope if any motor fails.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by cmurf on Thursday October 02, 2025 @10:24PM (#45458197)
As far as I'm aware 14 CFR 107 lacks anything like what applies to aircraft in case of power plant failure.

https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/part-91#p-91.119(a)

The catch all under both regulations is anything that's "careless and wreckless"

https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/part-107#p-107.23

https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/section-91.13

Was this particular operation careless and wreckless? Could be.

Someone else in the thread said the weather conditions included mist. I'm skeptical misty conditions also permits a minimum 3 miles of visibility, but what do I know I'm just a pilot.

https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/part-107#p-107.51(c)

But also, it's possible the waiver I assume Amazon is operating under could include visibility. I assume this because Part 107 requires visual line of sight operation, but Amazon's operation sounds like beyond visual line of sight (BVLOS). I don't know anything about that. I'd like to think the waiver and the operating requirements are public information, but I don't know that either.

https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/section-107.31

https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/part-107#p-107.205(c)

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by smcin on Thursday October 02, 2025 @08:05PM (#45457118)
Those FAA minimum altitudes apply to non-drone aviation. Not to drones.

For drones, there's a different set of FAA (and possibly state) rules.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by jahsome on Thursday October 02, 2025 @02:19PM (#45453373)
Just what I was looking for. Thanks for the context!
Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by CamperBob2 on Thursday October 02, 2025 @02:29PM (#45453491)
5 miles sounds pretty ridiculous, TBH. These things aren't moving at Mach 3.
Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by bell-cot on Thursday October 02, 2025 @03:02PM (#45453922)
At a mere (say) 240mph, 5 miles is 75 seconds. Talk to an experienced pilot about how short a time that is, when a bottom-10% pilot is trying to figure out some problem with his instrumentation, or has set his radio to the wrong frequency, or whatever.
Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by mr_toad on Thursday October 02, 2025 @03:32PM (#45454347)
> At a mere (say) 240mph, 5 miles is 75 seconds.

The world record holder for a quadcopter drone is 224 mph. Not many drones can beat 100 mph.

According to one article I found Amazons drones can manage 50mph.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by bell-cot on Thursday October 02, 2025 @05:03PM (#45455532)
5 miles at 50mph would give only Amazon 360 seconds to fix the bug that caused the first drone to crash. Or figure things out enough to get the second drone into manual override mode.
Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by spaqin on Friday October 03, 2025 @03:10AM (#45459949)
100mph is probably around the top speed for home built FPV quadcopters with 5 inch propellers; that's neither uncommon or expensive. Amazon's drones are probably built for efficiency though so they will go slower than that.
Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by oofbey on Thursday October 02, 2025 @02:53PM (#45453816)
Thanks for the context! Makes sense for traditional aircraft to be super conservative like this, especially given they tend to travel very long routes and sometimes have nothing more than a pair of human eyes paying attention to obstacles.

Do you know what are the rules for helicopters in a city? That seems like a closer analogue.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by stefan_ on Thursday October 02, 2025 @05:40PM (#45455931)
Why do people always get a hard on for bizarre drone rules? Some amateur pilot goes up in a fireball every other week, I think we put up their safety record to that of drones and there are going to be some hard choices to make - I think it's over for our amateur pilots out there.
Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by appreciatorBus on Thursday October 02, 2025 @08:40PM (#45457371)
TBH my concern is less for the fate of people who choose to fly planes or drones - they are the ones making the choice so if they hurt themselves that sucks, but none of my business. However I am concerned for the innocent bystanders who might be under them, who did not choose to risk death or injury by an aircraft, drone or otherwise.

The template for this ofc is how we handle (or don't handle) the danger posed by people inside cars, to people outside cars. In aviation we will do a lot to avoid even one death, in the air or on the ground. But in cars we mostly don't give a crap. It took decades for drunk driving to become unacceptable, but outside of that, we are still pretty ok with death by car. The only survivor of the collision just has to claim the person outside the vehicle "darted" and we all shrug and move on.

I would just love it if we could apply lessons of the past to new technology. Instead we just hand wave it all away. Then in a few decades, if enough people die and their surviving loved ones invest enough time & energy, maybe we'll make a few tweaks to the formula.

So no, we don't need 5nm separations for 20 lb drones. But we do need some sort of structure that recognizes the people under them didn't sign up to be part of the beta test. For bonus points it should also recognize that externalities exist and should be priced but I am not holding my breath.

Re:Two Amazon delivery drones crash into crane in commercial... by lawlessone on Thursday October 02, 2025 @01:53PM (#45453046)
not under it at a minimum lol