Say you have 2 people earning $30k/yr. One is trying to live frugally, the other is not. Suddenly the latter gets a $10k/yr raise "just by asking". I'd wager that the person with the deliberate, frugal mindset will still have more discretionary cash the day before payday than the one who got the raise.
If you want to get that salary raise, at some point it has to be backed by somebody actually buying something.
If everybody becomes super frugal then the economy shrinks and unemployment gets worse. I guess this is because we're at a point where we don't need anything close to 100% employment to cover everybody's 'basic' needs.
I remember when the recession started in the UK, there was a lot of advice going around to the effect of, "When you go shopping, don't buy brand name foods instead by the supermarket value brand equivalent'.
The supermarkets seem to have responded by simply taking a lot of the value brand products off the shelves or making them only available in bulk quantities.
This has a negative effect on equality. If your business is struggling because the lower and middle class aren't buying your products you must either decide to take lower margins or you will focus your products instead on the remaining people left who do have disposable income and start producing high end products only.
Because that's close to 900 calories.
I'm a student who's never had a full-time job in her life, and I have more money in savings than many well-paid professionals I know, simply because I actually put money into savings.
It's also helpful because the same technique that helped me earn an X% raise has worked over and over again, with roughly the same results. So when you learn to negotiate, you're changing the rate at which your income grows, as opposed to a one-time increase in income. That has a massive effect in the long term.
For what it's worth, if you're a HNer, I'll tell you something Ramit Sethi says often which would have been useful to internalize, oh, five years earlier: it is very hard to cut expenditures in such a meaningful fashion that your financial situation qualitatively changes. (There's only a few big wins there, and lattes or "stop buying books" do not qualify.) By comparison, the amount of impact you can have by moving your salary up is quite substantial indeed, particularly because there's just a crazy dynamic range in our industry and, well, most of us by default do not make choices which tend to land us on the top tiers of that range.
Seriously: I get people who email me on an almost weekly basis saying they got $5k ~ $15k a year just by asking for a raise. You know how many trips to the library it takes to move your financial situation by that much? You won't accomplish it in your lifetime. And that's between a few hours of work or, literally in some cases, minutes.