News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:33PM (#45434009)
> We couldn’t even handle a closed source experiment on earth (see biosphere 2), why would one on another celestial body fare any better?

Because (1) the project would be designed seriously and (2) you don't need a completely closed loop. Just one that's mostly closed.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by ipython on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:46PM (#45434070)
Who will design and execute this “seriously”? Given the current state of our government (shutting down as I type), I don’t foresee any “serious” projects from the feds any time soon. Even when there are serious people - everything will get politicized. So nasa is out.

Ok so maybe a multibillionaire. Perhaps Elon musk? Yikes. Or Bezos? Maybe.

The EU is kinda busy increasing their defense spend, preparing to engage in Ukraine so I don’t see them super excited to do this.

China or India perhaps?

Also, why shouldn’t it be completely closed loop? If you’re designing to address the myriad of scenarios that can unfold in space, I’d say you’d want that experience under your belt. Its already easy mode doing this exercise on earth you might as well give yourself a little challenge to capture lessons learned.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @03:24AM (#45435238)
> Who will design and execute this “seriously”?

NASA.

> why shouldn’t it be completely closed loop?

Because it doesn’t need to be. Engineering an ecological carbon cycle is hard. Putting in long-lived CO2 scrubbers is not.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by bunderbunder on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @11:08AM (#45438598)
I'd argue that you need a loop that's capable of operating without Earth support for a significant length of time - vastly beyond what they managed with Biosphere 2 - for margin of safety reasons. Possibly also with a very different, scaled down design - maybe not growing all their own food, for example - because 13,000 square meters is maybe a bit much for a first off-planet base. And the best place to start working out how to do that is right here on Earth. Because it's an immediate cost reduction of at least one and probably several orders of magnitude, and because you can much more easily iterate on the design while you're still working out the kinks.

And then, once you've got it working well here on Earth, then you have a go at doing it on the moon.

This idea that the best place to get started on working out how to do these sorts of things is on the moon makes about as much sense as suggesting that the Space Shuttle program should have had astronauts rushing to work out the kinks of EVA missions in space instead of doing everything they could to test and practice procedures in swimming pools in an effort to learn as much as possible before you blow half a billion dollars on trying it out in orbit.

Re:Boeing has started working on a 737 MAX replacement by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 01, 2025 @04:28PM (#45443022)
> need a loop that's capable of operating without Earth support for a significant length of time

Agree. A moon base lets us test this out with real-world constraints as opposed to simulants.

We don’t know how to build ecological closed loops. But every failure mode of Biosphere 2’s was almost trivially solvable with expendable components. (The CO2 cascade being the simplest among them.)

> idea that the best place to get started on working out how to do these sorts of things is on the moon

It’s not. It’s the best next step. We’re doing a lot of pre-colonisation lab work already. And we will need to do more before establishing a moon base. The moon base is the interim goal—you don’t put astronauts in swimming pools without a plan for a Shuttle. And Biosphere 2 is a terrible swimming pool for anything we’d do on the Moon or Mars.