Re:Largest Mass Resignation in US History as 100k Federal Wo...
by SR2Z on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @11:42AM
(#45426956)
You generally expect the size of an organization to scale with the scope of its activities, especially if its activities include "healthcare" and "building roads."
Re:Largest Mass Resignation in US History as 100k Federal Wo...
by timr on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @12:06PM
(#45427272)
"Scope of activities", maybe, but there's no inherent reason that has to be equal the rate of growth in the population. You'd hope that government becomes more efficient over time.
Private organizations have profit constraints, and they're constantly striving to become more efficient, cut what doesn't work, and so on. Government has no such constraint.
Re:Largest Mass Resignation in US History as 100k Federal Wo...
by ryandrake on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @06:20PM
(#45431931)
To compare, Walmart employs over 2M workers, and as efficient as they are, they still need to scale with the size of their business scope. Whether it's a linear scale or a log scale, they need more and more people as they do more and more.
The fact that the same order of magnitude number of people can administer an entire country as the number of people that it takes to administer a bunch of stores is actually remarkable.
Re:Largest Mass Resignation in US History as 100k Federal Wo...
by SR2Z on Thursday October 02, 2025 @05:40AM
(#45447767)
The government has become more efficient over time and its size as a percentage of the population has reduced as the population has grown.
Government does have a constraint like that - it has to remain solvent. A government as powerful as the United States has many tricks it can use to do that, but at some point even it cannot do anything it wants.
Re:Largest Mass Resignation in US History as 100k Federal Wo...
by throw0101c on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @03:35PM
(#45430177)
> Why does government have to grow proportionally with the size of the population?
It does not, and did not:
Re:Largest Mass Resignation in US History as 100k Federal Wo...
by timr on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @04:14PM
(#45430654)
I'm responding to the parent's implicit assertion that the government should somehow naturally grow with the size of the population.
Arguing that it historically has not done so only makes my point. Nor is it an argument that government should not be smaller today.
So what? Why does government have to grow proportionally with the size of the population? This is not a given in any other organization.