Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by fredBuddemeyer on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @11:19AM
(#453955)
good question. recently there was a "capitalism as a ponzi scheme" article and i wrote that ponzi had better insight into nature than malthus. i can't see anything objectionable here - just an expression of opinion and an implicit comparison between tim o'reilly's thinking and that of thomas malthus. i got dinged 2 points for this and i just can't understand why. if there was a reason so be it but i dont understand why anonymous negativity like this is part of the system. it has made me hold back from further commenting... till now :)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by dcminter on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @11:31AM
(#453972)
I wouldn't have dinged you - but I don't think that the comment really added anything. Since as I understand it the karma's supposed to be about improving the SNR that moderation seems reasonable.
If you'd justified why you felt that Ponzi had a "better" insight than Malthus then it would have been a useful contribution.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by tome on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @07:08PM
(#455481)
Yes indeed. I think your comment was too brief. A statement without justification is not particularly interesting to me, and I imagine others felt the same and downmodded you.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by fredBuddemeyer on Tuesday February 03, 2009 @03:51PM
(#464641)
thanks that is the feedback i needed; it seems when an online community resonates with you this misleads you to think they would get anything you say. its a kind of projected myopia.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by graywh on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @12:28PM
(#454067)
Some people just down-vote anything they disagree with despite any merits the comment may have.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by petercooper on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @03:45PM
(#454561)
There was a thread about this on HN several weeks ago. In it, pg seems to imply (to me, at least) that the behavior you talk about is just fine.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=392228
I got modded down for suggesting people should not downvote posts that have merit but that they just disagree with.. but hey :)
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by graywh on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @04:25PM
(#455024)
Yes, I'm aware of pg's opinion.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by rokhayakebe on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @03:20PM
(#454376)
Exactly. I think every time you downvote, you owe it to every one else to explain why.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by Xichekolas on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @03:50PM
(#454633)
There was a thread long ago about this for those that are interested: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=147098
(And rokhayakebe, I agree, responding is infinitely more useful than anonymous downmodding, provided the response is civil.)
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by graywh on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @04:30PM
(#455046)
I see plenty of pointless, off-topic comments that deserved to be downvoted without explanation. But I agree that if you want to downvote just because you disagree, you should probably state your case why. Or upvote someone who already has.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by johngunderman on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @03:50PM
(#454639)
A new feature, perhaps? non-anonymous down-voting?
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by dasil003 on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @05:59PM
(#455373)
who's the arbiter of merit?
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by netcan on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @07:09PM
(#455482)
The person doing the voting.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by dasil003 on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @10:31PM
(#455749)
I meant it more in the sense of a koan
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by netcan on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @10:35PM
(#455754)
If a comment gets modded in the forest...
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by biohacker42 on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @11:57AM
(#454018)
Meh, I was down modded for asking who here likes the writing of Maureen Dowd and Bill Kristol.
Apparently asking that simple question bothered some people.
In no way can you let anonymous up or down modding affect you in any way. It's not like you can exchange your karma points for cash.
Let your honest opinion represent you, not your efforts to stay popular.
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by mixmax on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @11:36AM
(#453983)
I just modded you up to encourage you to start commenting again.
Remember to make it interesting :-)
Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by fredBuddemeyer on Tuesday February 03, 2009 @03:52PM
(#464645)
thanks - i think im gonna cry
:>