Re:Ask HN: Does karma affect what you write?
by LogicHoleFlaw on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @11:40AM
(#453990)
I try to make a point of upvoting well-written contentious posts which I disagree with. I actually end up upvoting many of the posts I respond to contrarily which seem to get unfair downvotes.
As for the effect of karma on my own actions, I know that I've refrained from posting poorly-reasoned or hasty posts even after I've written them. I try to get citations and other supporting evidence too, rather than just posting an unsupported opinion.
I have found that on a good site, that argument will also tend to be voted up, even if it's against the local dominant opinion, but that's just a side-effect.
I left Slashdot when I could no longer do that, and I felt it was because I'd plumbed the depths of idiocy rather than failing to write my arguments correctly. (You can never reach perfection, of course, but assuming I didn't become radically worse at it over the course of a year, the fact that it become virtually impossible implicates the community.)
Write well, ignore karma. If you're getting consistently downvoted after that, consider that you may not be a match for the community. (And I do mean "consider"; it's not proof, but it's worth considering.)
And yes, karma encourages groupthink, though it doesn't create it. A strong community can overcome that, but the pull is inexorable and continuous. Compared to other karma-based communities I've been in, this is still a ways away from group-think dominance, though.