Re:The Theatre of Pull Requests and Code Review
by jonahx on Friday September 26, 2025 @05:48PM
(#45391353)
I don't know -- these are fair points.
I do know that when I was using GH regularly on a team where a number of people wrote clean history, the problems you mentioned didn't come up, not that I can recall. So for the 90% case, let's say, you can do clean history on GH and get the majority of its benefits. But yes, I'm sure it's flawed especially in workflows where those types of problem arise often.
I think a workflow like this for atomic commits would be nice. tangled.sh supports it for jujutsu¹, and it looks really neat. But the existing code review interface is clearly designed for code review to take place at the MR level.
[1]: https://blog.tangled.org/stacking