News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Story of DOGE, as Told by Federal Workers by ModernMech on Friday September 26, 2025 @12:00PM (#45388003)
> Most of congresses appropriations can't be faithfully executed because they largely violate the tenth amendment

This is plainly untrue, as the constitutionality of these appropriations can only be established by a court. Bills signed into law are presumed constitutional and valid until an Article III officer decides otherwise. The system is: Congress writes the law, funds the law. President signs the law, executes the law. Court interprets the law, invalidates the law. You can't have the POTUS sign, execute, interpret, and invalidate laws.

Separation of powers is what made the government work. Right now the Article II branch is the one who usurped power, the Congress and SCOTUS abdicated power, and it's causing the government to fail at all levels. If you give the executive the power you want it to have, the entire thesis of the Constitution crumbles (as we are witnessing), so quoting it at this point is futile and meaningless until balance of power is restored.

Right now, what would happen if what you said is true, is every time a new executive comes in, he can invalidate not just the executive orders but all laws passed by the previous administration, on a whim; without review, evidence, or argument he can shut down agencies and choose not to enforce any laws that are politically expedient. That's not how to run a constitutional republic. It's certainly descriptive of another form of government, but here you were quoting the Constitution.

> At the times when the federal government was mostly within the constraints of the 10th amendment, federal spending was under 5% of GDP in non war-time.

You'd have to go back to 1929 to see that kind of spending level. Since then, we went through a great depression and got a New Deal for America, which means the Federal Government has a larger role. We can surely revisit that role, and that's kind of what's happening right now. But it's wrong to say that the spending levels circa 1930s are somehow ideal of more constitutional without presenting more evidence.

Re:The Story of DOGE, as Told by Federal Workers by mothballed on Friday September 26, 2025 @01:42PM (#45389080)
>Court interprets the law, invalidates the law. You can't have the POTUS sign, execute, interpret, and invalidate laws.

see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45388993 as to why it takes all three branches agreeing on the constitutionality of a law for it actually to be put in effect and why that doesn't create the kind of dictatorship you're envisioning.

>is every time a new executive comes in, he can invalidate not just the executive orders but all laws passed by the previous administration, on a whim; without review, evidence, or argument he can shut down agencies and choose not to enforce any laws that are politically expedient.

POTUS is bound by constitution, even if SCOTUS thinks following the constitution is unconstitutional. This doesn't create an unchecked executive -- the legislature can also check the executive by impeaching him if he violates the constitution.

>You'd have to go back to 1929 to see that kind of spending level. Since then, we went through a great depression and got a New Deal for America, which means the Federal Government has a larger role. We can surely revisit that role, and that's kind of what's happening right now. But it's wrong to say that the spending levels circa 1930s are somehow ideal of more constitutional without presenting more evidence.

Yes exactly, it was circa the 30s when the apparatus of the state really cranked up to exceed the constitutional constraints of the federal government. The courts would create a more lasting correction to the problem, but that doesn't mean POTUS isn't also bound to stop executing all the unconstitutional laws. A lot of this stems from fraudulent portrayal of intrastate commerce as interstate commerce, which means a great deal of the actions of DEA, ATF, FDA, EPA, etc cannot legally be funded nor most of the wildly unconstitutional provisions of the cherished tyrannical civil rights act.

Re:The Story of DOGE, as Told by Federal Workers by ModernMech on Friday September 26, 2025 @05:28PM (#45391207)
> This doesn't create an unchecked executive -- the legislature can also check the executive by impeaching him if he violates the constitution.

The impeachment clause is for high crimes and misdemeanors and is supposed to be an extraordinary procedure that takes an immense amount of time. It's not realistic to rely on it to prevent a President from selectively enforcing or ignoring laws on a day-to-day basis, especially considering it has never been successfully used to remove any president from office even in the case where Trump used his office to extort a bribe.

Anyway here's what James Madison had to say about your proposal in Federalst 47:

  "No political truth is certainly of greater intrinsic value, or is stamped with the authority of more enlightened patrons of liberty, than that on which the objection is founded. The accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary, in the same hands, whether of one, a few, or many, and whether hereditary, self–appointed, or elective, may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny. Were the federal Constitution, therefore, really chargeable with the accumulation of power, which the argument supposes, it would be the very worst of all possible governments."
> the state really cranked up to exceed the constitutional constraints of the federal government... this stems from fraudulent portrayal of intrastate commerce... a great deal of the actions of DEA, ATF, FDA, EPA, etc cannot legally be funded

See, this is the problem with giving a single person the power to decide which laws to implement. You've made sweeping statements about "fraudulent" portrayals and the government exceeding constitutional authority, but these are just your own conclusory assertions. It's not clear that any constitutional constraints were actually violated, that portrayals of intrastate commerce were fraudulent, or that agencies like the DEA, FDA, etc. cannot legally be funded. These claims are unsupported, in fact they are anti-supported by decades of judicial review. Given your position, the President could just decide to shut down those agencies just on the flimsy basis you have provided. That's not how the system works.

I and others have realized that, despite your frequent appeals to the Constitution and the Framers, you do not appear to genuinely support the idea of a constitutional republic. Instead, you seem comfortable with a king-like authority, a single individual wielding absolute control over the government. That's a legitimate position, but you should be upfront about it rather than twisting the Constitution to fit your ideology. You're never going to squeeze a dictator-shaped peg into a constitution-sized hole -- doing so destroys the constitutional order.

Re:The Story of DOGE, as Told by Federal Workers by mothballed on Friday September 26, 2025 @06:34PM (#45391696)
What dictatorship are you aware of where the dictator cannot make laws and can only refuse to execute ones that go outside the bounds of the powers constrained by those bound by our 10th amendment? (And then if he doesn't can be impeached, which you briskly just toss to the side because it's inconvenient for your dictator narrative.)

You are arguing in bad faith. You are attempting to portray me as advocating for a dictatorship when I'm advocating the constitution be followed to reduce the amount of laws and powers the government can impose on its citizens.

>See, this is the problem with giving a single person the power to decide which laws to implement.

This is an insanely incorrect take... The constitution requires the POTUS to follow the constitution. He isn't permitted to execute an unconstitutional law. That is not a dictatorship -- not only is he not allowed to make the law in the first place, he's not permitted even execute a dictatorial law even if he wants to! Imagine if your insane thesis was true, the president was bound to wait until the courts ruled on it. Congress could simply make a law that POTUS is required to capture the entire judiciary, and take them away to some forgotten island in the Pacific before they could even rule on it, and from thereafter they would have complete control of government. Of course, quite a crazy proposal, but somehow you damn my considerations on whatever worst take you can find and ignore that if most branches of government are ignoring the constitution the system has already been broken.

And it is this poisonous, treasonous ideology you are peddling that has result in it being so difficult to reign in these problems, because it's pervasive within the bloated sector of civil servants who fatly feast upon our populace and other benefactors of super-constitutional government who relentlessly seek to stop the clawing back of the dictatorship of various entities like the ATF (which changes "guidance" without changing law and somehow binds it on people as law and then arrests them for it, acting as both executive and legislature).

I think this really exhibits an impassable divide in this country, that we're seeing come to a head. One side think's your literally a dictator if you try to reduce the power of the federal government by asking each branch to refuse unconstitutional directives. To not be a dictator, you have to be comfortable with the legislator constantly introducing laws that go so far as to regulate growing wheat on your own land for in situ consumption (Wickard v Filburn) under the interstate commerce clause, and because the judiciary says that is fine the president just has to enforce it. And if he doesn't, well that's a dictatorship.

Utter nonsense.

Re:The Story of DOGE, as Told by Federal Workers by ModernMech on Friday September 26, 2025 @07:43PM (#45392167)
> poisonous, treasonous ideology you are peddling

And with that we are done. Have a good one.

Re:The Story of DOGE, as Told by Federal Workers by mothballed on Friday September 26, 2025 @07:45PM (#45392174)
Have a nice weekend!