News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Identity Types by auggierose on Friday September 26, 2025 @04:06AM (#45384006)
> Obviously they're different, but they're equivalent for most purposes

That is not even wrong. You are mixing up syntax and semantics, and that is because type theorists don't have a concept of semantics.

Re:Identity Types by lmm on Friday September 26, 2025 @05:02AM (#45384381)
> That is not even wrong. You are mixing up syntax and semantics, and that is because type theorists don't have a concept of semantics.

Right back at you. I don't have to treat notation as something different from semantics, because I'm working in a theory that can handle both elegantly and consistently. Conventional mathematics struggles to describe mathematics as it is actually performed - working mathematicians rely extensively on "abuse of notation", but set-theoretic metamathematics pretends this is out of scope or safe to ignore.

Re:Identity Types by auggierose on Friday September 26, 2025 @08:31AM (#45385745)
If you say that semantics and syntax are the same, then you don't have semantics. That is not elegant, just confused, and your statements in this thread here are a great example of that.