Re:The Theatre of Pull Requests and Code Review
by m000 on Friday September 26, 2025 @07:06AM
(#45385108)
Everything works, until it doesn't.
You always have the PR discussion to refer to, until you move to a different platform to cut costs.
You can always ask the author of the code, until they have left the company.
Why waste time? Just squash and merge, you have a single commit and it WORKS
> You can allow intermediate commits to e.g. fail the tests, and add a tag to your main/master after each merge. Then you know that only the tagged commits are guaranteed to be fully functional.
OR… squash and merge. Block merging with tests and compilation passing
For anything in tech, there’s the frictionless way and the busywork way. Both of your examples are busywork that’s completely unnecessary if you just… squash and merge
The best process is the process nobody needs to remember to do shit for it to work