Re:The Theatre of Pull Requests and Code Review
by lucyjojo on Thursday September 25, 2025 @07:50PM
(#45380828)
maybe if the majority of devs switched to jj or something similar your idea might become semi-common. but it seems to me that currently for most most project, it generates a lot of cost for very little gain.
My personal idea is that the code in each PR should be well documented enough for a review, but also for when people join the team and need to learn. Or when a pour soul needs to check upon your code while you are out on a holiday. This personal rule does not apply to all projects, but for bread and butter stuff I tend to go by it and not care about clean commit histories. The cost to reward seems way better.
My personal idea is that the code in each PR should be well documented enough for a review, but also for when people join the team and need to learn. Or when a pour soul needs to check upon your code while you are out on a holiday. This personal rule does not apply to all projects, but for bread and butter stuff I tend to go by it and not care about clean commit histories. The cost to reward seems way better.