News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by stetrain on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @08:44AM (#45359515)
I think treating the government as a singular entity pushing a narrative is missing a bit. There is no singular government moving in lock-step, I think we've seen a lot of those seams showing recently.

There are factions, supported by various wealthy powerful interests. Those factions include people in government but also people funding or controlling media.

The owner and CEO of a major social network was literally given a public-facing government position, and others in the administration were previously TV personalities.

Wealth, media, and government are an ouroboros, not a one-directional megaphone from The Government to The Citizens.

Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by herval on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @09:04AM (#45359743)
This is true in a _well functioning democratic government_ - by design: as long as there are differences, a single actor cannot take over.

Understanding that the media is owned by powerful people, and people have agendas, is a key point to media literacy that should be taught at schools. It doesn't mean media should be ignored, nor that they always aim to manipulate (with some exceptions). It's, again, healthy if you understand it as it is (a viewpoint, espoused by people with a specific worldview). Interpreting the news require critical thinking. Most people never develop critical thinking.

Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by potato3732842 on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @09:52AM (#45360405)
>a single actor cannot take over.

This is a distinction without a difference. People can screech about "we're a democracy, we don't have a king" all they want but if the overwhelming amount of discretionary authority in the system is held by a fairly small group of people cut from approximately the same cloth it doesn't really matter, they're all gonna decide things the same ways and the results are gonna be just as divorced from what people want.

It doesn't matter if you have a thousand people working to appease the ideological whims of one absolute ruler or a thousand people with the same set of ideological whims, it's still one set of ideological whims being worked towards.

Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by herval on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @10:04AM (#45360591)
it's a distinction with A TON of difference. Well-functioning democracies have a push-and-pull that tends to slow things down BUT also prevents massive outreaches. Systems with tons of "sides" are stabler than dual systems because of this.

> It doesn't matter if you have a thousand people working to appease the ideological whims of one absolute ruler or a thousand people with the same set of ideological whims, it's still one set of ideological whims being worked towards.

that's exactly the point - there's a third option.

Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by potato3732842 on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @10:22AM (#45360844)
>it's a distinction with A TON of difference. Well-functioning democracies have a push-and-pull that tends to slow things down BUT also prevents massive outreaches. Systems with tons of "sides" are stabler than dual systems because of this.

Right, a democracy won't succumb to one insane leader peddling particularly insane whims the way a dictatorship possibly can. But for the other 99/100 years of the century when things are business as usual it's a distinction without a difference.

The fact that we have a nominal democracy doesn't change the fact that we're being ruled by the small ideological minority that holds the bulk of the power in the system.

>that's exactly the point - there's a third option.

Yeah, we could have a government by some semblance of the people and all the diversity of that implies, but we don't, at least not to any serious degree at the federal level, so here we are.

Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by herval on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @11:58AM (#45362179)
> But for the other 99/100 years of the century when things are business as usual it's a distinction without a difference.

"business as usual" under a totalitarian regime is slightly different from "business as usual" under a democratic regime. We have plenty of examples of both in the world right now. They're not equivalent...

Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by 0xDEAFBEAD on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @12:40PM (#45362816)
You're contrasting dictatorship vs oligarchy. The key differentiator for democracies is leaders who are subject to re-election incentives.

Populist parties are surging all over the world. Perhaps there are a few modern democracies where all the political elites are "cut from approximately the same cloth", but if so, they aren't countries I am very familiar with.

Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by UpsideDownRide on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @09:22AM (#45359967)
Lack of critical thinking is a bit of a worldwide schooling system failure. Underfunding on one hand and not having an education plan for people to develop those skills leads to what we have. Some are lucky to get those skills from home or from top tier schools.

I imagine that this state of things was somewhat beneficial for the ruling elites but Russia is now showing the whole western world, that dumb population is a huge liability.

Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by herval on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @10:05AM (#45360603)
Indeed it is - and likely by design anyway (critical thinking is bad for political control, after all). You generally want the ones in power (preferably the ones aligned to you) to be better educated than the masses.
Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by pixl97 on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @10:44AM (#45361160)
In a 'well functioning' aristocracy the rich and titled tend to go to the best universities and get educations an such. In authoritarian governments the opposite tends to happen. Anyone that is too smart could take over and rule themselves and must have an accident before that can happen. You end up circled by ass kissers.
Re:That Secret Service SIM farm story is bogus by potato3732842 on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @09:47AM (#45360328)
Sure, it's a bunch of silos made up of sub-silos with people with their own goals.

But, I have far too often seen this "the government isn't a monolith" assertion used in the most deceitful, dishonest irredeemably bad faith arguments here on HN (and other parts of the internet as well) to shut down discussion of cases where some subset of the government is doing things that are bad for it's own selfish reasons.

Ditto for the "they're not literally conspiring" assertion used to shut down discussion of cases of where interests align and no conspiring or active coordinate is needed to achieve the results.