News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pocket Casts, You Altered the Deal, So I Will Alter Your App by hiAndrewQuinn on Monday September 22, 2025 @11:52PM (#45342666)
Well, does anyone actually have a copy of the contract from 14 years ago? Usually there are clauses hedging against this kind of thing.

Example: I recently wrote the T&S for my Finnish dictionary app (still working on it), and I make it clear in advance that the license was a one time fee for perpetual use for that major version. [1]

I can do this because the app is almost entirely offline, and because for the parts that are, smart cloud infra decisions means my recurring infra costs are low. If I add in features which imply a bespoke server down the line, of course that would probably be a major version upgrade - and a change in the pricing model to boot. But I'd still keep the old v1 stuff up for the lifers.

[1]: https://taskusanakirja.com/terms-of-service/#91-pricing-and-...

Re:Pocket Casts, You Altered the Deal, So I Will Alter Your App by anon-3988 on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @12:31AM (#45342860)
IIRC they advertised themselves as "pay once, use forever" in their marketing. So why shouldn't they uphold that?
Re:Pocket Casts, You Altered the Deal, So I Will Alter Your App by hiAndrewQuinn on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @01:59AM (#45343258)
An advertisement is not a contract, unfortunately. If we're going to talk legal, we need to talk in legalese.
Re:Pocket Casts, You Altered the Deal, So I Will Alter Your App by Zagorath on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @03:46AM (#45343994)
They are (or were, at the time they had that slogan) an Australian company. I am an Australian citizen. Under Australian Consumer Law, an advertisement is absolutely legally binding.

https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/advertising-and-promotions...

Re:Pocket Casts, You Altered the Deal, So I Will Alter Your App by theshrike79 on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @07:15AM (#45345433)
So if an Australian ad tells something is "the best" or something similar and you can prove it isn't, you can get your money back?
Re:Pocket Casts, You Altered the Deal, So I Will Alter Your App by Zagorath on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @09:54AM (#45347084)
The link I shared makes it quite clear that "puffery" that nobody is reasonably expected to take literally does not count.

Being told that the app you paid for would be a one-time payment, and then having the service deliberately degraded to try and force you into a subscription model, is clearly not puffery.

Re:Pocket Casts, You Altered the Deal, So I Will Alter Your App by packetlost on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @11:19AM (#45348302)
Usually subjective opinion isn't binding (though I'm sure there are exceptions to this across jurisdictions)