Re:Everything's broken and nobody's upset
by rbanffy on Monday September 17, 2012 @02:48PM
(#4534164)
> Making stuff work is hard
Making complicated stuff work is hard. There is a reason some people design tools to do one thing and do it well - it's easy to be sure it does that one thing correctly all the time and easier to check it keeps doing it.
Maybe we're betting our simplicity on the stack we build upon (I certainly build a lot of simple stuff on top of very tall stacks of mostly simple stuff), I'm not sure there are no surprises hidden in it. However, we should strive for making things (machines, software) that are simple inside. When we do that, it's easier to make the simplicity transpire and become an elegant form-follows-function kind of design. It will not be possible to avoid all bugs, but by making conscious decisions against complicated designs, we may make some lives less miserable.
Making complicated stuff work is hard. There is a reason some people design tools to do one thing and do it well - it's easy to be sure it does that one thing correctly all the time and easier to check it keeps doing it.
Maybe we're betting our simplicity on the stack we build upon (I certainly build a lot of simple stuff on top of very tall stacks of mostly simple stuff), I'm not sure there are no surprises hidden in it. However, we should strive for making things (machines, software) that are simple inside. When we do that, it's easier to make the simplicity transpire and become an elegant form-follows-function kind of design. It will not be possible to avoid all bugs, but by making conscious decisions against complicated designs, we may make some lives less miserable.