News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hardware is dead by jgrahamc on Monday September 17, 2012 @01:08PM (#4533565)
"At these levels there is almost no profit margin left in the hardware business. A $45 tablet is cheap enough to be an impulse purchase at the check-out line in Best Buy. A $45 price puts tablets within reach of a whole host of other activities not traditionally associated with computers. Tablets could be used by waiters in restaurants."

I've been to plenty of restaurants where waiters having been using handheld, wireless devices to take orders, so that's nothing new. And claiming that a rapid price drop means there's "almost no profit margin" and then equating that to the death of hardware seems completely upside down.

If hardware manufacturing has dropped to the point where complex devices are cheap to buy then we are entering a golden age of hardware since it means that manufacturing and design process has got cheap enough that many things that were previously too expensive to design/manufacture will be made.

It can also herald an era of 'mom and pop' hardware companies.

Re:Hardware is dead by freshhawk on Monday September 17, 2012 @01:49PM (#4533805)
"... then we are entering a golden age of hardware ...

It can also herald an era of 'mom and pop' hardware companies."

Exactly!

I never understand bloggers and pundits who analyze these things from the perspective of the stockholders or owners of the large players instead of the consumers/small players.

Why the hell would you cheer about the high margins charged on the products you are paying for? Is marketing getting so good that consumers are now complaining about too much competition among those they buy from?

Re:Hardware is dead by michaelt on Monday September 17, 2012 @07:35PM (#4535458)

  Why the hell would you cheer about the high margins 
  charged on the products you are paying for?
I don't cheer high margins, but in some industries cheap medium-low quality products crowd more expensive higher quality products out of the market.

Consider inkjet printers; there are many cheap products on the market, but the consensus opinion among techies seems to be that there's no suppler with a good product.

It would be a shame if more of the technology industry went in that direction.

Re:Hardware is dead by freshhawk on Monday September 17, 2012 @08:02PM (#4535539)
I'm not sure inkjet printers are a good example, although you can say that since the cheap printers flooded the market there are fewer "good" printers and they lost the economies of scale so they are more expensive.

This example is so polluted by the whole ink cartridge "sell the razor blades" business model and the legal challenges around 3rd party cartridges that I would be very hesitant to generalize from the printer example.

With that said, the kindle business model is that same model so maybe there is something to it.

Re:Hardware is dead by Spooky23 on Tuesday September 18, 2012 @01:01PM (#4539211)
Products are low-margin. Solutions are high margin.

There isn't much money in selling commodity tablets. But there is a huge amount of money out there in solutions built around tablets.

Re:Hardware is dead by mef on Monday September 17, 2012 @01:55PM (#4533843)
Not sure if you were referring to the article author, but Jay Goldberg is a financial analyst with an investment bank.
Re:Hardware is dead by freshhawk on Monday September 17, 2012 @02:21PM (#4534003)
More referring to the general trend, even among commenters.

This is not a perfect example, since you can make the argument that the audience is other investors who want to some trend forecasting and have a generally conservative mindset.

But it does bring up another possible reason for this behaviour: for those with a stake in maintaining the status quo it now makes sense to attempt to fight commoditization through marketing/lobbying disguised as journalism now that ethics in journalism is ebbing and the cost to publish a blog is low.

I personally think it's a result of the success so many brands have had in tying brand choice to personal identity and tribal affiliation, but that doesn't apply to the writer of this piece obviously.

Re:Hardware is dead by andywhite37 on Monday September 17, 2012 @03:41PM (#4534443)
It could also mean that "mom and pop" companies can no longer get into the hardware game at all. If there is no margin for hardware sales, only companies that can afford to setup the manufacturing processes and operate them at little, no, or negative profit will be able to stay in the game. This means only companies like Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Google, etc. who can afford to support mass hardware production with software sales, will be able to compete in the hardware market.
Re:Hardware is dead by drumdance on Monday September 17, 2012 @02:38PM (#4534110)
Also, it's interesting that he brags about his research in China without mentioning what this means in developing economies. China still has huge segments of the population that do not own tablets, not to mention India.

Meanwhile in the developed world, tablets could become as ubiquitous as signs.