Re:Oxford loses top 3 university ranking for the first time
by danlitt on Sunday September 21, 2025 @03:59PM
(#45326125)
When I was there (maths, 2010s) it was 1 supervision per course per fortnight. You had 4 problem sets in an 8 week course (for long courses). 16 lectures meant 3 sets, 12 lectures meant 2. I never heard of a college doing more than 2 students in a supervision.
Re:Oxford loses top 3 university ranking for the first time
by exe34 on Sunday September 21, 2025 @02:48PM
(#45325511)
cue the Harvard graduates tell us they had 5 teachers for 1 student in their tutorials.
A large part of uni is about learning to learn on your own and learning in groups - if everything is spoonfed, it might not be the best training.
Re:Oxford loses top 3 university ranking for the first time
by ninalanyon on Sunday September 21, 2025 @05:05PM
(#45326639)
We certainly didn't get spoon fed in tutorials at Exeter Uni. in the 1970s!
Re:Oxford loses top 3 university ranking for the first time
by 2dvisio on Sunday September 21, 2025 @05:21PM
(#45326771)
Tutorials are all but spoon-feeding. Tutors are strongly encouraged not to give just solutions, but actually to teach the approach to solving problems and creating connections with adjacent topics where possible.
When I was at Cambridge in the early noughties, supervisions for maths and computer science (and physics I believe but I didn't go to any of those) were 2 students in 4 1-hour sessions per week (1 per 24 hour lecture course). [Edit: hmm, actually maybe it was just 2 per week.] In maths, if there were an odd number of students then one would get 1 to 1 supervisions, but I'm sure that depends on the college. For computer science, I was put in a 3 person supervision when they had an odd number (and I wasn't happy about it at the time!)
I later did teaching at UCL and Imperial and the difference was huge. When they get to it, I would advise my children to go Oxford or Cambridge in a heartbeat. (For reference, my parents were too poor to even consider university.)