News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Was Supposed to Help Juniors Shine. Why Does It Mostly... by nicce on Sunday September 21, 2025 @07:26AM (#45321809)
> Really does not sound like that from your description. It sounds like coaching a noob, which is a lot of work in itself.

Even if you do it by yourself, you need to do the same thinking and iterative process by yourself. You just get the code almost instantly and mostly correctly, if you are good at defining the initial specification.

Re:AI Was Supposed to Help Juniors Shine. Why Does It Mostly... by fsloth on Sunday September 21, 2025 @09:26AM (#45322520)
This. You _have_ to write the spec. The result is that instead of spending X units of time on spec and THEN y units of time on coding, you get the whole thing in x units of time AND you have a spec.

The trick is knowning where the particular LLM sucks. I expect in a short amount of time there is no productivity gain but when you start to understand the limitations and strengths - holey moley.

Re:AI Was Supposed to Help Juniors Shine. Why Does It Mostly... by skydhash on Sunday September 21, 2025 @10:21AM (#45322989)
> The result is that instead of spending X units of time on spec and THEN y units of time on coding, you get the whole thing in x units of time AND you have a spec.

It's more like x units of time thinking and y units of times coding, whereas I see people spend x/2 thinking, x typing the specs, y correcting the specs, and y giving up and correcting the code.

Re:AI Was Supposed to Help Juniors Shine. Why Does It Mostly... by fsloth on Sunday September 21, 2025 @11:20AM (#45323540)
Sure! That's inefficient. I know just how I work and I've been writing the type of programs I do for quite many years. And I know what would take me normally a week takes me few days at best.
Re:AI Was Supposed to Help Juniors Shine. Why Does It Mostly... by nicce on Sunday September 21, 2025 @04:08PM (#45326190)
But if you can’t define the specs, you can’t write the code without LLM either?
Re:AI Was Supposed to Help Juniors Shine. Why Does It Mostly... by smsm42 on Sunday September 21, 2025 @11:33AM (#45323659)
Unless you realize no LLM is good at what you need and you just wasted weeks of time walking in circles.
Re:AI Was Supposed to Help Juniors Shine. Why Does It Mostly... by fsloth on Monday September 22, 2025 @08:40AM (#45332593)
If you notice only after two weeks the project is off-kilter I would guess the chance of that happening without an LLM is not low either.

These are not _tools_ -they are like cool demos. Once you have a certain mass of functional code in place, intuition - that for myself required decades of programming to develop - kicks in and you get these spider sense tinglings ”ahh umm this does not feel right, something’s wrong”.

My advice would be don’t use LLM until you have the ”spider-sense” level intuition.