Re:X11 Window System Turns 25 Years Old
by ChuckMcM on Saturday September 15, 2012 @04:04PM
(#4527136)
I strongly agree with that sentiment. Strangely perhaps, I expect many of the original X advocates probably would as well. X was created at a time when computers had 1/50,000th the power they do today by inverse Moore's law reasoning 2^(25/1.5). From a graphics performance perspective its probably closer to one five-millionth the equivalent power by the reasoning that a full frame (1920 x 1080) specularly lit frame can be rendered in 16 mS today vs 86400000 mS 25 years ago. So you had a choice, you could either render a UI, or you could do computation, but not both.
On top of that the only way to control a complex remote application was something like X because having 15 80x25 terminals wasn't cutting it.
The web browser and markup, combined with the advancement in local processing/rendering ability completely destroyed one of the fundamental problems X was trying to solve. That it didn't kill X right then and there was, in my opinion, an artifact of the implementation as a glorified telnet session for the HTTP server.
On top of that the only way to control a complex remote application was something like X because having 15 80x25 terminals wasn't cutting it.
The web browser and markup, combined with the advancement in local processing/rendering ability completely destroyed one of the fundamental problems X was trying to solve. That it didn't kill X right then and there was, in my opinion, an artifact of the implementation as a glorified telnet session for the HTTP server.