This said, less potential vendors supplying packages 'may' reduce exposure, but doesn't remove it.
Either way, not running the bleeding edge packages unless it's a known security fix seems like a good idea.
- npm should require 2FA disallow tokens for publishing. This is an option, but it should be a requirement.
- npm should require using a trusted publisher and provenance for package with over 100k downloads a week and their dependencies.
- Github should require a 2FA step for automated publishing
- npm should add a cool down period where if won't install brand new packages without a flag
- npm should stop running postinstall scripts.
- npm should have an option to not install packages without provenance.
Sure, there will be a step/stage that will require access to NPM publish credentials to publish to NPM. But why does this stage need to execute any code except a very small footprint of vetted code? It should just pickup a packaged, signed binary and move it to NPM.
The compilation/packaging step on the other hand doesn't need publishing rights to NPM. Ideally, it should only get a filesystem with the sources, dependencies and a few shared libraries and /sys or /proc dependencies it may need to function. Why does some dependency downloading need access to your entire filesystem? Maybe it needs some allowed secrets, but eh.
It's certainly a lot of change into existing pipelines and ideas, and it's certainly possible to poke holes into there if you want things to be easy. But it'd raise the bar quite a bit.