Re:GPT-5-Codex
by wahnfrieden on Monday September 15, 2025 @05:46PM
(#45255342)
It is 100% true. And they are rapidly losing users to Codex. Charts were shared recently showing a massive migration underway.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:GPT-5-Codex
by CuriouslyC on Monday September 15, 2025 @08:24PM
(#45256599)
Oh yeah, Sonnet performance has been in the toilet for me. They claim they've mitigated it but when 4.0 first dropped CC was really impressive, and now I constantly have to babysit it because any time it hits a challenge it'll just stop trying and make a simple toy version and declare false victory. If I don't catch it and I let it build on top of that bullshit, things get nasty in a hurry.
It's a shame because the plan is a great deal but the number of all caps and profanity laced messages I'm firing off at Claude is too damned high.
Re:GPT-5-Codex
by wahnfrieden on Monday September 15, 2025 @11:14PM
(#45257662)
GPT-5 is comparable to Opus without needing to constantly dip back down to Sonnet for cost management
Yes, this. I feel like Iām going crazy. I pay for the extra Opus usage and I keep checking the model switcher to see if it has automatically switched to Sonnet. It has not. I just have a lot more experiences of it feeling anecdotally dumb lately.
This hits home for me too. Claude feels like it has gotten more "yes-man"-y. I can no longer trust its judgement. Even if I come in with something dead wrong, I'm "absolutely right" and it finds amazing ways to spin my BS into something vaguely believable.
I am also bullying Claude more nowadays. Seeing this thread, I might give Codex another go (I was on Codex CLI before Claude Code. At that time, Claude blew Codex out of the water but something's changed)
Am I missing something? That.. doesn't seem to be true? https://npmtrends.com/@anthropic-ai/claude-code-vs-@openai/c...