News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @12:20PM (#452403)
The crux of the article is this: "So the bottom line for me is that the venture capital business is not going to solve this problem we are in. We are going to play a role, possibly an important role, but we'll need more forms of job creation to get everyone back to work."

That, I wholeheartedly agree with. Unfortunately, it seems that it will take a while for housing prices to deflate enough and for people's wage expectation to decrease enough that utilizing American workers becomes cost effective again. Will there be enough capital around to finance the shift of production back home? Will other countries continue to underbid domestic goods? Are we in fact heading to a more "normal" level of unemployment (we have usually had a comparatively low rate, globally speaking) ?

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by alecco on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @12:56PM (#452469)
IMHO, solving the problem will be much harder than that. US is highly based on a plan of idealized life through media. A typical lifestyle of the suburbs:

  * Multiple cars per family and doing heavy commuting.
  * Huge houses with high bills and maintenance.
  * Consumerism based on filling those houses and cars with non-essential disposable items.
All those millions living with that mindset apply those same rules at work. There are great exceptions, but their size is not relevant to the national bottom-line.

Now apply that to venture and you get what doesn't work. PG is on this problem often. Perhaps a bit too Socratic-style for my taste. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socratic_method)

I never understood how the economy worked in the US with so much waste. Now with this crisis I get it, it never did. US needs a culture shock urgently. (A bailout is more of the same, IMHO.)

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by astrid on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @01:40PM (#452504)
Wich also means that America has a confortable margin to improve. Their own genius lies in pragmatism, I wouldn't bet against them when necessity joins the game.
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by alecco on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @02:36PM (#452583)
Indeed! US was a beacon of freedom before the Bush administration, together with France. Making an analogy to free software, US is BSD and France is GPL. For example France forces its citizens to be free, like a recent case denying citizenship to a very submissive Muslim-traditionalist woman as she was admittedly waiving her rights for her husband's.

Also US has a gigantic human capital with well educated population. It is a bit hard, but IMHO the change has to start with media. Perhaps applying existing laws against the advertisement cartel. But this is the French-style of freedom. I don't know.

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by yters on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @06:35PM (#452987)
That's a funny kind of freedom.
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by omouse on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @07:50PM (#453085)
Not really. It's freedom defending itself. The freedom to take away your own freedom...sounds kind of silly don't you think?
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by netcan on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @12:57AM (#453394)
I've thought about these kinds of things often lately. Freedom defending itself, democracy defending itself & such. What should be done about anti-democratic parties in a democratic society? Those kinds of things.

I am coming to the conclusion that you hit a breaking point if this becomes to big an issue. Sure it's ok to handle it one way or another if the above party is at <5%. But once they near the 50% mark, it's game over. You cannot defend democracy or freedom without compromising it.

Same goes in this case. When it's a once a year case, that's one thing. But if you have a large number voluntarily relinquishing freedoms, it is no longer a free state.

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by yters on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @01:45PM (#454197)
My view is that as long as relinquishing one's own freedom does not impact the freedom of others, then it should slide. This assumes the person relinquishing is doing so voluntarily and with full knowledge of the alternatives.

Otherwise, it isn't really freedom in the libertarian sense, since people should be free to do what they want as long as it doesn't harm others. Plus, what makes a person feel free can vary from person to person, so if "freedom" is being mandated as in France, then it can actually become totalitarian in the name of "freedom."

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by netcan on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @05:49PM (#455355)
Say you have a democratically elected anti-democratic party. Or even a large minority party. It's usually not so straightforward because democracies & demi-democracies normally disallow these. But they do exist. Currently theocratic movements lead the trend.

If you allow these to run, you get a theocracy. If you disallow it, you no longer have a democracy. As long as they're small you can suppress them in the name of defending democracy. But defending democracy against the demos really ends democracy if it is in any way substantial.

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @01:29PM (#452489)
Now with this crisis I get it, it never did

You're summing up 50 years of post WWII history into the last 10 years? Good luck with that. The economy works just fine with hat you call "waste." Nothing humans do will ever be close to 100% efficient for any length of time. We're messy that way! The bottom line is that most people the world over will generally live just within their means (or just over if there is sufficient credit) and you may as well get used to that. Living "efficiently" is normally done only by those who have little in the way of resources (in which case they're normally living barely within their means), or by the handwringing worriers who have plenty but feel guilty about it.

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @01:45PM (#452516)
Have you looked at household debt vs wage since WWII?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt-to-income_ratio

What we are seeing is the unraveling of that process -- since the 30 year fixed mortgage was widely available from the FHA and the VA, the amount of debt we've been willing to shoulder has increased over time.

With increased living expenses (college costs, et cetera) and flat wages, how have americans maintained their standard of living?? Home Equity lines of credit... MORE DEBT! Living on less isn't just for "handwringing worriers who have plenty but feel guilty about it", it is the prudent thing to do.

Then again, prudence isn't hot or hip.

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by jonhohle on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @10:40PM (#453269)
i think people don't think about how easy access to loans/funds inflates the price of a good. banks were falling over themselves to give people money, and realtors were happy to take as much of it as they could; if no one has $500,000 for a house, houses aren't going to cost $500,000.
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @01:40PM (#452502)
It also isn't globally scalable -- consider the acres per person that the American lifestyle requires.
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by gravitycop on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @08:30PM (#453138)
consider the acres per person that the American lifestyle requires.

Progressively less over time. http://www.juliansimon.com/writings/Ultimate_Resource/TCHAR2...

If Americans, engaged in their current lifestyles, constituted the entire 6.7 billion head population of the world, less land would be required than is required today.

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by alecco on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @01:54AM (#453451)
That is just personal space, not the whole system to support it.
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by gravitycop on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @02:08AM (#453456)
That is just personal space

No, it is all of the required space. Most of the linked page regards farming space. Did you read it?

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by jodrellblank on Tuesday January 27, 2009 @08:15PM (#453118)
Consider the acres per person that America has.
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by alecco on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @01:51AM (#453450)
He probably means the amount of acres required to support the suburban lifestyle. For example it demands more roads, more mining operations, more resource extracting for goods and energy. You don't see it as much because that gets outsourced, too. China is already suffering the consequences of this with the worst pollution levels in history. Remember this affects us all in the long run.
Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by gravitycop on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @02:23AM (#453470)
to support the suburban lifestyle [...] demands more roads, more mining operations, more resource extracting for goods and energy.

A mine is not a permanent use of land. Greater demand for mined materials does not imply greater numbers of mines. Existing mines might simply be made deeper. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bingham_Canyon_Mine And the minerals in greater demand might also be substituted (e.g. copper for telecommunication wires by silicon for fiber optics).

Regarding the potential for being paved over by suburbia: http://www.juliansimon.com/writings/Ultimate_Resource/TCHAR0...

of the 2.3 billion acres in the U.S. as of 1987, all the land taken up by cities, highways, non-agricultural roads, railroads, and airports amounts to only 82 million acres - just 3.6 percent of the total. Clearly there is very little competition between agriculture on the one side, and cities and roads on the other.

Concerning the trends: from 1920 to 1987, land in urban and transportation uses rose from 29 million acres to 82 million acres - a change of 2.3 percent of the total area of the U.S. During those fifty-seven years, population increased from 106 million to 243 million people. Even if this trend were to continue (population growth has slowed down), there would be an almost unnoticeable impact on U.S. agriculture, just as in past decades (see figure 9-2).

Concerning the notion that the U.S. is being "paved over," as of 1974 the U.S. Department of Agriculture's official view was that "we are in no danger of running out of farmland."

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by alecco on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @02:59AM (#453491)
You conveniently skipped the outsourced bit (China.) And that is a very shallow investigation. For example, the fertile arable land available is running out. That is as hard a fact as there is.

Cities grow usually on fertile land, and large suburbs make this problem several times bigger.

In the last couple of years there were thousands of protests around the globe because of food prices. You might not notice it as it's probably only a fraction of your costs, but for many (most?) people in the world it is their main expense. And most of the food gets sent to the best payer automagically. The quota system to cope with hunger is gone:

http://www.newyorker.com/talk/financial/2008/11/24/081124ta_...

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by gravitycop on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @03:11AM (#453500)
the fertile arable land available is running out.

Fertile arable land is made out of rock. The earth is made out of rock. If the earth - as you imply - is running out of itself, where do you suppose it - rock - might be going? Does rock get used up by farming in it, and thereby disappear?

Normally, when something is becoming scare ("running out"), people 1) make more of it, 2) use it more efficiently, and 3) substitute other things for it. In the case of arable land, we have observed people 1) making fresh arable land out of rock, 2) reclaiming arable land from wetlands/lakes/oceans/hillsides/mountainsides, and 3) substituting in the forms of vertical and soil-free agriculture and other forms.

As I noted previously, "A mine is not a permanent use of land." http://www.juliansimon.com/writings/Ultimate_Resource/TCHAR0...

Both ignorance and mysticism enter importantly into conventional thinking about farmland. For example, one hears that "once it's paved over, it's gone for good." Not so. Consider the situation in Germany, where entire towns are moved off the land for enormous stripmining operations. After the mining is done, farmland is replaced, and the topsoil that is put down is so well enriched and fertilized that "reconstituted farmland now sells for more than the original land." Furthermore, by all measures the area is more attractive and environmentally pure than before.

-

that is a very shallow investigation. [...] Cities grow usually on fertile land

Did you read it? Here is the link again: http://www.juliansimon.com/writings/Ultimate_Resource/TCHAR0...

But what about the fertility of the land used for human habitation and transportation? Even if the total quantity of land used by additional urban people is small, perhaps the new urban land has special agricultural quality. One often hears this charge, as made in my then-home town in the 1977 City Council election. The mayor "is opposed to urban sprawl because 'it eats up prime agricultural land.'"

New cropland is created, and some old cropland goes out of use, as we have seen. The overall effect, in the judgment of the U.S. Department of Agriculture, is that between 1967 and 1975 "the quality of cropland has been improved by shifts in land use ... better land makes up a higher proportion of the remaining cropland."

The idea that cities devour "prime land" is a particularly clear example of the failure to grasp economic principles. Let's take the concrete (asphalt?) case of a new shopping mall on the outskirts of Champaign-Urbana, Illinois. The key economic idea is that the mall land has greater value to the economy as a shopping center than it does as a farm, wonderful though this Illinois land is for growing corn and soybeans. That's why the mall investors could pay the farmer enough to make it worthwhile for him or her to sell. [...]

The person who objects to the shopping mall says, "Why not put the mall on inferior wasteland that cannot be used for corn and soybeans?" The mall owners would love to find and buy such land - as long as it would be equally convenient for shoppers. But there is no such wasteland close to town. And "wasteland" far away from Champaign-Urbana is like land that will not raise whornseat - because of its remoteness it will not raise a good "crop" of shoppers (or whornseat or corn). The same reasoning explains why all of us put our lawns in front of our homes instead of raising corn out front and putting the lawn miles away on "inferior" land.

Re:22 years of job creation wiped out in a day by gravitycop on Wednesday January 28, 2009 @03:23AM (#453509)
>> all the land taken up by cities, highways, non-agricultural roads, railroads, and airports amounts to only 82 million acres - just 3.6 percent of the total.

> You conveniently skipped the outsourced bit (China.)

U.S. urban sprawl is outsourced to China? If so, how so?