News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by omh on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:37PM (#4523820)
Imagine that you're in charge of a small/medium sized business , stuck on Windows XP and some old email system. You've just persuaded the managers that "The Cloud" isn't so bad, and they've migrated everything over to Google Apps.

Now Google have just given you 8 weeks notice about support for IE8. Unlike traditional software, after this date you're screwed - you can't just not upgrade, you're actually cut off from the software you were planning on using.

Now, you can probably install Chrome or Firefox. If you're lucky, that won't cause any problems elsewhere. But what happens next time? If Google decide that they don't want to support any client on XP, or perhaps the iPhone? What do you do then? When this starts happening over the next couple of years we'll start seeing a backlash against the current trend towards the cloud.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by mbrubeck on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:49PM (#4523881)
This isn't 8 weeks notice. It's a reminder about a policy that was announced fifteen months ago. Administrators have had plenty of time to migrate away from Google Apps or figure out how to deploy newer browsers on time.

http://googleenterprise.blogspot.com/2011/06/our-plans-to-su...

Users of unsupported browsers aren't locked out; they just see a message telling them to upgrade, and some functionality might eventually degrade. Degraded functionality is documented at:

http://support.google.com/a/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=3...

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by omh on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:56PM (#4523915)
My understanding is that the old policy included support for IE8. This new update removes that.

This is important because IE8 is, in practice, the latest version of IE for many corporate users. It's also fully supported by Microsoft. We're not taking about Windows 2000 or IE6 here.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by cstejerean on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:33PM (#4524091)
Sure, back then it included IE8, but the announcement specifically stated "Beginning August 1st, we’ll support the current and prior major release...", and with IE10 coming out, IE8 is no longer included in that category. When IE11 comes out you can expect Google will also drop support for IE9 and so on.
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by omh on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:47PM (#4524154)
Ah yes, fair enough.

Part of the problem here is Microsoft's limit of IE9+ not running on XP. This is either a sensible technical requirement or a deliberate push away from XP, depending on your perspective.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by yuhong on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:57PM (#4524194)
Yea, in general, MS do not release new versions of IE for a Windows version in extended support, which for XP happened just after IE8 release in April 2009.
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by Silhouette on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:58PM (#4524199)
That's an awfully convenient excuse for shafting a very significant number of customers (or potential customers) running platforms that are far from ancient or unreasonable.

The current version of Windows is Windows 7, and as yet there seems to be no indication from Microsoft that IE10 will be supported on Win7. Does that mean if they release IE11 next year, my brand new computer that I buy tomorrow won't be able to run Google's web apps any more?

Even now, IE9 is not supported on WinXP, which was effectively the most recent acceptable version of Windows until around 3 years ago and is still within its official support period from Microsoft. More importantly, it's still in extremely widespread use.

I can't imagine a more compelling argument that Google could make to show that we shouldn't trust them or their cloud infrastructure as a reliable, future-proof service. Apparently they believe that grown-ups running professional IT departments with real support requirements should stick with centrally administered desktop software for anything critical. Not exactly the message you'd expect them to be sending if they want to encourage more customers, particularly the lucrative big business market, to migrate to their cloud services...

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by mbrubeck on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:49PM (#4525066)
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by Silhouette on Saturday September 15, 2012 @07:02AM (#4525870)
Those articles appear to be rather out of date.

More recently (within the last month or so), there's been a lot of IT media interest in whether IE10 will be available on Windows 7, but recent platform previews seem to have supported Windows 8 only and Microsoft have been conspicuously quiet on the matter. Just google "IE10 Windows 7".

This isn't to say that IE10 won't support Windows 7 in the end, but right now the picture isn't looking good.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by tomjen3 on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:37PM (#4524117)
The old policy is the same as the new policy.

The only thing that changes is that MS is going to release IE10 and, in accordance with the policy, support for IE8 will end after that.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by rjbond3rd on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:58PM (#4523924)
As a recovering web dev, I am absolutely thrilled to see older browsers aggressively cut off from support :)

But for the hypothetical company stuck on XP, it seems (to me) contradictory that they would migrate to the cloud but not to a modern browser/OS. Still, I'm sure there are some out there.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by jamesaguilar on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:44PM (#4523851)
Tough nails, IMO. Google probably ran these numbers and feels they can afford to lose the few customers they have in this situation. That someone can come up with a sob story that MIGHT happen because of some deprecation doesn't mean there's a case for supporting old browsers.
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by thezilch on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:33PM (#4524090)
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by icelancer on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:01PM (#4523934)
Too goddamned bad. If you're stuck on WinXP / IE8 and some old email system, stick with appropriately old shit. No one cares about these people.
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by onetimeuse001 on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:32PM (#4524087)
Suffering from hypothermia? Many are enterprise users, and this can mean a strike against Google Apps. Many of them stick with XP because it works great for their purpose and many applications only work with IE.

Like it or not, Microsoft wins a lot of points for supporting older versions for a decade plus. They might lose a few bucks on a new Windows license but make it back on reputation and other enterprise tools.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by tomjen3 on Saturday September 15, 2012 @06:12AM (#4525803)
It doesn't matter that they are enterprise users. Enterprises have held back the state of the art for decades. The fact that google has to drag them into the recent past and hear this much screaming is only an indication of how backwards they are.

The world is changeing and the enterprises will have to adapt.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by lysol on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:49PM (#4524167)
A company still using an operating system released 10 years ago probably sees little merit in migrating to hosted email, calendars, etc. They most likely have an old Exchange system that they are maintaining alongside those XP workstations. I doubt this affects many organizations.
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by Silhouette on Friday September 14, 2012 @06:29PM (#4524320)
Windows XP might have been available for a decade, but you have to consider that Vista flopped and Windows 7 only arrived around 3 years ago.

That means large numbers of organisations were still installing Windows XP as their standard desktop around 3 years ago, and possibly even more recently than that since they wouldn't necessarily have evaluated Windows 7 and set up to migrate to it from day 1.

Moreover, the days of upgrading hardware every 2-3 years are gone, at least in typical office environments that aren't really pushing the performance limits of a typical office PC any more.

In other words, for large organisations that keep relatively up-to-date, it's still entirely possible that they have a lot of WinXP machines still around today, even if their newer machines are on Windows 7 now.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by NameNickHN on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:46PM (#4523867)
Where should installing Firefox or Chrome cause problems?
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by omh on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:53PM (#4523898)
Several of my users have business-critical websites that only work in Internet Explorer. I can set up shortcuts so that Firefox is used for some sites and IE for others, but that can get confusing.

Also, both Firefox and Chrome are extremely lacking in options for managing user settings. Things that can be set with a group policy for IE require manual scripting for Firefox.

Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by jonknee on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:16PM (#4524009)
Google isn't ending support for IE, just IE 8. If you're on XP and can't get a newer IE you can certainly use another browser. The number of people locked in IE and XP and are completely cloud based is probably very small.
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by r00fus on Friday September 14, 2012 @07:57PM (#4524582)
Does IETab or Chrome Frame not work for these deployments?
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by hmahncke on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:53PM (#4523897)
Sadly, lots of places.
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by NameNickHN on Saturday September 15, 2012 @05:29AM (#4525757)
This is just FUD. What places?
Re:Google Apps update alerts: Internet Explorer 8 support di... by hmahncke on Sunday September 16, 2012 @12:24PM (#4529464)
I didn't mean that to sound like FUD. I work with a number of insurance companies that are on XP/IE7; with a Firefox install requiring approval from a large IT department.