News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by ljf on Saturday September 13, 2025 @12:15AM (#45229247)
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by adastra22 on Saturday September 13, 2025 @12:23AM (#45229279)
Wtf? Ok I guess so. I would have never guessed.
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by lanfeust6 on Saturday September 13, 2025 @08:14AM (#45231427)
Its a favorite among degrowthers and those who romanticise life in primitive societies
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by uncircle on Saturday September 13, 2025 @11:58AM (#45233112)
Also a favourite among those that compare apples to oranges.
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by verisimi on Saturday September 13, 2025 @02:57AM (#45229936)
It is really great that Snopes was around in medieval times and can confirm or deny! /S

The thing is, no one knows what medieval peasants were doing, cos we weren't there. We have this or that piece of evidence, but evidence can be misinterpreted.

Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by bigstrat2003 on Saturday September 13, 2025 @03:50AM (#45230168)
The majority of people today don't work as hard as the farmers of today. It is completely implausible that they work harder than the farmers of the middle ages, who almost certainly had to work harder than modern farmers (thanks to no mechanization).
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by BriggyDwiggs42 on Saturday September 13, 2025 @12:17PM (#45233262)
That’s not really a fair comparison when vastly more of the population worked as farmers. The article has a good bit of evidence though that the amount of food needed to feed laborers didn’t lower meaningfully during the period cited as having short work hours, while the economic record that statistic is based on is very spotty. They probably worked way more hours.
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by bluGill on Saturday September 13, 2025 @06:48AM (#45231027)
We know enough facts to get a good picture even if we don't know exactly what they were doing\
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by antisthenes on Saturday September 13, 2025 @10:52AM (#45232558)
I think the origin of the trope is that the peasants sat around doing nothing during winter, when there was nothing to plant or harvest.

It's probably true that there was less work in the winter (although you still had all your maintenance tasks, e.g. repairs and preparing firewood), but this was compensated by much more intense labor in the spring and summer.

Overall, though, it makes no sense to say medieval peasants worked less than people do now, it's likely very comparable, and the variations would depend on the quality of your soil/irrigation and how much you were going to get taxed.

Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by ljf on Saturday September 13, 2025 @05:21PM (#45235424)
Totally agree - their lives were no doubt hard and busy with back breaking work - my 'yes' was a 'yes it is a trope' - not a 'yes they barely worked'
Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by dot1x on Tuesday September 16, 2025 @07:57AM (#45261032)
Ehm... definitely NOT!

> Ultimately, we found that the claim that medieval peasants worked around 150 days a year is still largely accepted as a valid estimate by academic economic historians, at least in England for a period starting around 1350 and lasting between a few decades and more than a century, depending on the methodology used to study the data.

Re:Life, work, death and the peasant: Rent and extraction by ljf on Tuesday September 16, 2025 @05:13PM (#45268143)
As below; Totally agree - their lives were no doubt hard and busy with back breaking work - my 'yes' was a 'yes it is a trope' - not a 'yes they barely worked