News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI's $344B 'Language Model' Bet Looks Fragile by pmdr on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:59AM (#45212450)
One can call into question the paucity of AI-critical posts & comments here on HN. Not much is being said about the economics, everybody's living off the hope that "they'll figure it out." And AGI is just a few hundred-billion-dollar loans away, so why quit while we're ahead?

If they do "figure it out" (both AGI and a viable business model), a lot of people here will likely be out of a job. If they don't, the whole thing will come crashing down, taking our invested savings with it.

The comparison to crypto keeps coming up. Not everyone's savings went into crypto, but a lot of people's savings and retirement funds are being invested in funds tied to the stock market. And right now its growth depending on pumping cash into the AI bubble.

Re:AI's $344B 'Language Model' Bet Looks Fragile by simianwords on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:15PM (#45213330)
The answer is so easy to solve.

Do I find value in paying 20 dollars a month for ChatGPT? Yes. Do others? As far as I can see, yes. Most people are happy with the value.

Are AI companies profitable if they stop R&D? Yes.

Where’s the skepticism coming from?

Re:AI's $344B 'Language Model' Bet Looks Fragile by pmdr on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:17PM (#45215693)
I'd actually be content knowing $20 a month covers inference and makes them a decent profit, but I have my doubts. If there's proof out there that it does, I haven't found it yet.

> Are AI companies profitable if they stop R&D? Yes.

By what metrics? Where's the data?

Re:AI's $344B 'Language Model' Bet Looks Fragile by simianwords on Friday September 12, 2025 @04:34AM (#45220010)
We're profitable on inference. If we didn't pay for training, we'd be a very profitable company

- Sam Altman

Re:AI's $344B 'Language Model' Bet Looks Fragile by pmdr on Friday September 12, 2025 @07:19AM (#45220957)
This statement is probably all we're going to get out of a private company that's a long way from making a profit. Personally, I'd like to see data, because I don't really trust whatever twisted definition of "profitable" Altman prefers. Until then I'll take advantage of the $20 price tag, but remain skeptical about its sustainability.
Re:AI's $344B 'Language Model' Bet Looks Fragile by simianwords on Friday September 12, 2025 @08:39AM (#45221488)
Lets assume that it is not profitable now because inference is too costly. Do you think making inference 20% more efficient would make it profitable? Or 60%?
Re:AI's $344B 'Language Model' Bet Looks Fragile by pmdr on Friday September 12, 2025 @11:55AM (#45223540)
No idea, we don't even have ballpark numbers about that. If they ever truly & transparently become profitable, there will be billions to pay back to investors -- I don't think anyone treats OpenAI like a charity project. At that point I highly doubt the subscription will still be $20.