News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AdBlock, NoScript & Ghostery – The Trifecta Of Evil [Opin... by hollerith on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:59AM (#4520813)
>The internet was already a pretty neat place before online advertising became ubiquitous.

It was already a very neat place when it tolerated almost no advertising at all.

Under the restrictions on "commercial use" that were in place until 1993 or so, although it was allowed for a job hunter to post his resume (to a newsgroup like ba.jobs whose purpose was to connect job hunters and employers), looking for contract work rather than permanent employment was not allowed because it was considered advertising of consulting services and consequently a commercial use.

I liked the internet of 1992 a great deal. I couldn't use it to buy nutritional supplements or shoes, and I couldn't use it to reconnect with old friends from high school (since those old friends were not on the internet) but it was a better tool for learning than the community college I was attending at the time.

Re:AdBlock, NoScript & Ghostery – The Trifecta Of Evil [Opin... by zbychuk on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:06PM (#4522685)
Really? You were happy without search engines, without google maps, without Microsoft or Apple download pages, without any social sites, without wiki? Maybe you were, I was not.
Re:AdBlock, NoScript & Ghostery – The Trifecta Of Evil [Opin... by hollerith on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:44PM (#4523270)
Well, gee, did you take me to be advocating that the internet should go back exactly to where it was in 1992? How about putting a little effort into finding an interpretation of my comment that doesn't make me that dumb / perverse?

The context of my comment was advertising. In particular I was presenting evidence against the OP's assertion that things like Adblock Plus might ruin the internet.

In an alternate universe in which advertising had never been introduced on the internet, someone would probably have made maps available through the internet by now (Nokia had online maps for their phones that were probably (I am actually not entirely sure) not supported by ads), Microsoft and Apple would have download pages (why would they depend on ads?), and all the wikis I care about (the original wiki, namely http://c2.com/cgi/wiki, Wikipedia and various small or smallish wikis created by specialized communities) would have developed more or less like they actually did.

Re:AdBlock, NoScript & Ghostery – The Trifecta Of Evil [Opin... by msfd on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:26PM (#4524056)
Wikipedia and OpenStreeMap would actually be possible since they are not commercial...