Re:Math anxiety causes trouble for students as early as firs...
by rdtsc on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:02AM
(#4520300)
That makes me so angry. We live in the 21st century, we fly to the moon and rovers to Mars and build microchips yet we can't teach our kids math effectively.
I have seen these books, I have seen this "everyday"-type approach to math also in college for non-technical majors. I looked at Everyday Math links.
They are a disaster. It is simpler to explain the goddam subject than to find round-about "simple" problems and "games" that somehow distantly refer to math but are meant to be "easy" when in fact they are nothing but confusing. They build their own "easy" terminology that is non-standard and they go and apply it.
The decimals for example. They go about in 10 round-about ways (base-10 block, wtf are those?) before finally showing a number line and asking students to order them. The number line is probably the most useful. I remember learning this from exercises. No base-10 blocks, no "math facts" (why not call them theorems and axioms). Just lots of exercises. Eventually the student internalizes the relationship and builds an internal abstract model.
The confusing part is all these "easy" terminology that tries to help in the end it all looks like an onslaught of random stuff pushed onto the student. They don't know that the author is trying to carefully orchestrate this long and drawn out process of presenting "math facts" so in the end the student reaches an "aha" moment and gets. He gets lost among orange circle with blue borders, playing coin-top-it and base-10 blocks in the end never really reaching the intended "aha" moment be she got stock at the "Decimals All Around Museum"
I have seen these books, I have seen this "everyday"-type approach to math also in college for non-technical majors. I looked at Everyday Math links.
They are a disaster. It is simpler to explain the goddam subject than to find round-about "simple" problems and "games" that somehow distantly refer to math but are meant to be "easy" when in fact they are nothing but confusing. They build their own "easy" terminology that is non-standard and they go and apply it.
This is the crap I am talking about:
http://everydaymath.uchicago.edu/about/understanding-em/EM20...
The decimals for example. They go about in 10 round-about ways (base-10 block, wtf are those?) before finally showing a number line and asking students to order them. The number line is probably the most useful. I remember learning this from exercises. No base-10 blocks, no "math facts" (why not call them theorems and axioms). Just lots of exercises. Eventually the student internalizes the relationship and builds an internal abstract model.
The confusing part is all these "easy" terminology that tries to help in the end it all looks like an onslaught of random stuff pushed onto the student. They don't know that the author is trying to carefully orchestrate this long and drawn out process of presenting "math facts" so in the end the student reaches an "aha" moment and gets. He gets lost among orange circle with blue borders, playing coin-top-it and base-10 blocks in the end never really reaching the intended "aha" moment be she got stock at the "Decimals All Around Museum"