Twitter is getting pressure to start making returns, and it is obvious that the author doesn't like advertising - but what does he think would be a solution?
I've been noticing a trend in backlash towards advertising over "social" platforms (e.g. App.net), but other than the Public Broadcasting Station model, how else can they cover costs?
Looking at the author's revision to the Twitter Quadrant at the bottom of the article, it may be this:
1. Fun!!!
2. ???
3. Profit!
---I've been noticing a trend in backlash towards advertising over "social" platforms (e.g. App.net), but other than the Public Broadcasting Station model, how else can they cover costs?
The bit.ly model is what the Twitter Quadrant reminds me of - providing service A for free, then providing service B (analytics of service A) for a price.
The problem is, the advertising isn't separate from the editorial.
Having a promoted Tweet is the equivalent of a friend turning to you at dinner and say "Man! I could sure go for a Duff Beer right now. With its clean filtered taste and low alcohol rate - it's the Beer that keeps on giving. Duff!"
I've sketched out some ideas in the comments here and on the blog. I'm but a lowly geek - I don't profess to have the cast iron formula to help Twitter get an ROI.
I just know this way leave me (and many others) deeply dissatisfied.
The problem with Twitter is that they grew to hundreds of millions of free users before figuring out a business model. At that scale, the only model that's proven to work is ads.
Author here. I don't think Republicans are dumb - but I'm not convinced I'd want to invest in a company run by Bush http://edition.cnn.com/ALLPOLITICS/stories/1999/05/13/presid...
On to your main point. Sentiment analysis is still imprecise - but seeing as the majority of my (news) links go to The Guardian or Independent, and none go to tabloids - it's not a stretch to say I'm unlikey to visit a News International title.
I've never (knowingly) Tweeted or otherwise interacted with The Sun.
That's one example out of many. At one point, I was sent targetted tweets about attending a conference in the USA - I live in the UK.
If they were blindly targeted, it wouldn't feel so offensive.
This is the laziest form of writing I can think of and it makes you look juvenile. I have trouble taking anything you say seriously after that sort of nonsense, and I'd suspect that a big chunk of your readers are the same.
--
Okay, you didn't tweet the sun, but you linked to a picture of somebody else who did. I'm sorry I don't know who you are well enough to recognize that handle as not yours.
This is a serious question: how would twitter know what you're interested in? It's not a computational linguistics engine, it's a datastore. Explain to me how you would draw these connections if you had access to all of twitters data.
I don't know where you get the impression that I linked to someone who did tweet The Sun. I linked to a screenshot I had taken.
Finally, Twitter is selling itself to advertisers as knowing about its users. If it doesn't, it better get to some of the fancier universities around the world and snap up the computational linguistic majors.
>I am suggesting that Twitter is being run by MBAs and that (some) MBAs are [...] useless
Then say that. The pointless jab is just that: pointless.
>it better get to some of the fancier universities around the world and snap up the computational linguistic majors.
Is this a joke?
What do MBA's even have to do with this situation? Dick Costolo isn't an MBA; he's a UMich CS grad. He's been running tech startups since I was in high school.
You feel offensive, because Twitters' data analysis isn't sophisticated enough to understand your personal interests well enough?
I want to give you my heart felt apologies. I am one of these people responsible, who try their very best to sabotage these profiling systems and putting effort into creating distortion and unrelated data. I hope you can wait a little longer for that day, your when all the ads shown to you are echo-chambering your believe set and reaffirming any (political) biases you have.
If a company is going to do advertising - they should do it well.
I'm not sure if you're British, but rejecting The Sun doesn't mean I reject their political viewpoint - it means I reject their sexist, homophobic, lying, and (allegedly) criminal actions.
You seem convinced that this ad being targeted to you was some massive failure of Twitter's ad product. I am not sure that is the case.
Premium Twitter advertisers (of which the Sun is surely one) have a variety of targeting options that could explain why you saw this ad.
The Sun may have simply targeted all accounts in the UK. Or, they may have targeted accounts that follow other UK publication accounts (it looks like you follow a few Guardian accounts for example).
It is clear that you didn't want to be targeted by The Sun, but that doesn't mean that The Sun didn't want to target you.
You might as well argue that those who think the Daily Mail is stupid are suppressing free speech and re-enforcing their echo chamber. You would look like just as much of an idiot as you do now.
Nobody forces them to buy the Sun - never the less over two million people buy the paper every day. Are you seriously arguing that a paper that 10% of Britain reads every day should be banned from advertising on Twitter, just because you disagree on their reporting style?
Living in a free society means that you have to tolerate different opinions to your own. Sure, if they break certain laws, go and prosecute them.
People arguing on issues like these based on their personal views are in my opinion no better to these who want to ban porn from the internet, because it their personal value judgment says it is wrong.
I find it hilarious that you consider what the Sun does to be reporting. Like those hard-hitting journalists at the Weekly World News. How dare I tarnish their sparkling reputation with my disparaging of their highly regarded journalism style.
> Are you seriously arguing that a paper that 10% of Britain reads every day should be banned from advertising on Twitter, just because you disagree on their reporting style?
No, I'm arguing they're an indefensible tabloid rag so aligning yourself with them is risky. Nobody is discussing "banning" except you. I would prefer Twitter doesn't accept their advertising dollars and if I see a Sun ad in any of my clients I'm quitting too.
The number of people who read their idiotic rag is neither here nor there. If you're seriously suggesting that at the very least 10% of any group isn't comprised of borderline retards, then you're delusional.
Using my eyeballs and wallet to vote isn't "banning", it's exactly what I'm supposed to do. Vocalize my concerns, try to get a response, and if they're not receptive, take my business elsewhere.
Please try to refrain from ad hominem attacks as it doesn't help in proving your point.
http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. E.g. "That is an idiotic thing to say; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."I'm sorry, if someone tries to argue that the Jersey Shore or Bad Girls Club is quality television, if they try to argue that Katy Perry makes amazing original music, that McDonalds is fine cuisine, or if they claim the Sun does real reporting, I'm going to call them an idiot.
Even if it affects my argument negatively, it has to be said. I'm not just going to let that stand because it's an opinion. It's a painfully ignorant opinion, stemming from the "muddy the waters" argument that has become so popular.
So? I live in Sweden, yet I've attended conferences all over Europe and in Canada. A couple of years ago my girlfriend was in South Africa for a conference. We have these things called airplanes which makes that sort of this quite convenient. If there's an interesting conference in the US then why wouldn't I want to hear about it?
>Harvard – one of the most prestigious universities – awarded an MBA to George W Bush. A man many of us wouldn’t trust to sit the right way round on a toilet.
As a reason not to trust Harvard. The world gets it. Those republicans surrreee are dummies.
/puke
The rest of your article is a bit naive. Computational linguistics is not considered a solved problem yet. Yes, twitter might have 26,000 or some odd tweets from you, but that doesn't mean that they "know" anything about you. It's dumb text.
In fact, now that you've tweeted at the sun newspaper, how is twitter to know that you aren't interested in that newspaper? You're interacting with it, of course you would want to see ads from it, right?
This [meaning targeted advertising] works for facebook (although arguably well since the meme is that facebook ads don't perform) because of the "like" system. I target ads at people who have "liked" things, not at people who have talked about them.