I never met anyone else in person in the 90s who also used the internet
Quite a few young people were on the internet in the early '90s, but almost entirely university students. I noticed quite a few from GB on Usenet. I remember perusing threads about English 'raves' since the rave phenomenon had barely reached America.NameZero was from 01999 evidently: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/namezero
When I joined a couple other guys working to build the southeast US's fastest growing ISP in early mid-90s, enough mom and pops, small businesses, and government agencies -- from backyard bird feeder webcams to US Navy recruiting -- were already staking their brochureware claims that it was worth marketing ourselves as offering FrontPage hosting.
Windows 95 already took you online fine, while Windows 98SE bundled IE 5 which included the first version of XMLHttpRequest, giving birth to Ajax, enabling single page apps... and of course e-commerce in ad banners.
By the time you are calling the early Internet, everyone called it Web 2.0, and most things are still that.
Interestingly, I met tons of teens from rural UK in early 90s online, in MUDs and MOOs and especially Talkers such as Surfers: https://muds.fandom.com/wiki/Surfers (Small world, several went on to found or lead top web 2.0 digital agencies.). As a sibling comment notes, most were at uni.
By that time, the early 90s, it was then considered the end of the early Internet, beginning of mainstreaming. US law changed to allow making money online, Web 1.0 got its footing, and most of all, it was the start of Eternal September: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
From my point of view at the time, companies like NameZero and Xoom were Johnny-come-lately scumbags in danger of destroying the internet through their flagrant disregard for its culture and traditions. Looters. And, from today's perspective, I'm not sure I was wrong.