News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by ars on Thursday September 13, 2012 @06:58AM (#4515540)
How is an adapter a valid way to obey the law? The goal is that you don't have proprietary chargers in the box. i.e. the goal is the charger, not the phone.

If apple sells the phone with their charger, that has a proprietary interface that are not obeying the law, adapter or no adapter.

To obey the law the charger must have a microUSB connector on it, and they need to offer phones with no charger at a lower cost as an option.

The goal is to reduce waste, instead apple is increasing it with this adapter.

Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by m_eiman on Thursday September 13, 2012 @07:13AM (#4515572)
The charger has a normal USB-A female connecter, so you can connect any USB cable that will fit in a computer to it. So the charger itself isn't limited to Lightning, but can be used with a USBA->microUSB cable.

Also see http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/sectors/rtte/chargers/questio... that says:

Which is the agreed common interface?

On the basis of the Micro-USB interface, the companies have agreed to develop a common specification in order to allow for full compatibility of chargers and mobile phones. These specifications have been translated in European standards.

N.B.: The agreement allows for the use of an adaptor.

Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by buro9 on Thursday September 13, 2012 @07:25AM (#4515605)
> N.B.: The agreement allows for the use of an adaptor.

That doesn't make sense unless Apple ship adaptors for both the charger and phone.

As your parent said, the goal is very clearly to have one charger be capable of charging any mobile device.

So... can the Apple charger be used on the Nokia? If not, then they also need to make available an adaptor the other way around.

The whole point is to not ship chargers at some point. If Apple make it so that other chargers can charge the iPhone but the Apple charger cannot charge anything else, then Apple are still outside the spirit of the law.

They need to provide 2 adaptors. The charger must charge a Nokia, and a Nokia charger must charge an iPhone.

Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by taligent on Thursday September 13, 2012 @07:34AM (#4515629)
Yes. The current Apple Power->USB charger works just fine at charging Nokia devices. And no reason why it would be any different now.
Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by buro9 on Thursday September 13, 2012 @07:44AM (#4515659)
If the only cable provided in the box with the iPhone is this one: http://store.apple.com/uk/product/MD818ZM/A/lightning-to-usb...

A USB > Lightning cable.

Then how can I take any phone off my desk and just charge it? The Nokia doesn't have a Lightning interface.

And if they don't supply a cable with a male microUSB end, then how are they complying?

It's not like the last video on this page doesn't make the purpose eminently clear: http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/sectors/rtte/chargers/index_e...

In Europe, they should ship a microUSB charger and give everyone the adaptor too.

Then, we have one charger for all... and the iPhone can be charged using the adaptor.

That's not ideal for Apple and it is a less than elegant solution given the lightning port, but the whole point is to put a common consumer and the environment before the corporations and proprietary interfaces (and chargers).

Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by antirez on Thursday September 13, 2012 @07:18AM (#4515585)
Also, functionally speaking, the idea is that if you have your phone in your pocket and you have no charger with you, any charger of any other phone will do it. It is not the case if you need an adapter.
Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by sdfx on Thursday September 13, 2012 @08:58AM (#4515886)
As I understand it, it's not a law but an agreement among the industry:

  > As a result, world leading mobile phone producers committed
  > themselves to ensure compatibility of data-enabled mobile phones,
Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by epo on Thursday September 13, 2012 @07:12AM (#4515569)
You want to apply to Apple for a job as a lawyer, you obviously think you know more about the law then they do.
Re:Apple reveals Lightning to microUSB adapter to pacify Europe by cico71 on Thursday September 13, 2012 @07:58AM (#4515697)
Well, their lawyers apparently thought to know well the laws about warranty around Europe and they got fined...