Re:Over 80% of Sunscreen Performed Below Their Labelled Effi...
by aero_code on Saturday September 06, 2025 @10:40PM
(#45154917)
But sunscreen doesn't stop all damage to skin. I spent weekdays working inside on a computer, then sometimes spent summer weekends outside in the sun. I get sunburned easily, sometimes in like 10 minutes of direct sun. You wouldn't try to deny a light sunburn isn't skin damage? SPF 50 suncreen, blocking 98% of sun, extends the 10 minutes by 50x to 8.3 hours, but that is still not that great. I can still exceed that in two days. And I don't see why having light skin and wanting to spend the weekend outside would be unusual. Blocking 99% of UV and doubling the time over 98% would help quite a bit.
Re:Over 80% of Sunscreen Performed Below Their Labelled Effi...
by treis on Saturday September 06, 2025 @11:35PM
(#45155174)
That isn't how sunscreen works. If you put SPF 50 on and spend 8 hours in the sun you're coming back a lobster.
Say you burn in 5 minutes. SPF 50 means you burn in 250 minutes. But it's more like 100% protection for 245 minutes and then 0% for the last 5. It's not a steady cooking at 2.5% intensity.
Re:Over 80% of Sunscreen Performed Below Their Labelled Effi...
by rcxdude on Sunday September 07, 2025 @09:53AM
(#45158159)
Got any source for that? Everything I can find (and the intuitive explanation of it) points to the opposite: SPF is how much of the UV blocks, not at all how long the sunscreen stays on your skin (which varies wildly with what you're doing).
Re:Over 80% of Sunscreen Performed Below Their Labelled Effi...
by treis on Sunday September 07, 2025 @11:28AM
(#45159042)
https://cdnmedia.eurofins.com/apac/media/609921/spf-iso-prot...
That's my entire point. The way they generate SPF measures how much of the sun it blocks in the lab shortly after it's applied. That one blocks 97.5% and another 98% is meaningless for the real world.
I disagree. Both effectively stop all damage to the skin. It's like having 10 inches of steel armor for bullet proofing instead of 1. A bullet isn't getting through either so they are equally effective.