News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Watchmen" As a Primer on Mental Disorder by anamax on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @05:14PM (#4513271)
> The end doesn't justify the means

If the ends don't justify the means, what does?

The problem is actually on the other side. The means produce the end. Not intentions, not the morals of the persons involved, but the means. Fascism, for example, is the result of fascist acts, no matter who does them or their reasons for doing so.

That fact seems to be lost on "good people".

Re:"Watchmen" As a Primer on Mental Disorder by DigitalJack on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @06:52PM (#4513708)
There is a food shortage in Africa. One way to solve this would be to kill 80% of the African population.

The end (solved food shortage) does not justify the means (mass murder).

The means must be able to stand on their own.

Re:"Watchmen" As a Primer on Mental Disorder by reinhardt on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @07:39PM (#4513892)
That's a poor metaphor. The end is to keep the population alive. Solving food shortage is (one) means. Failing to mass murder them is another.
Re:"Watchmen" As a Primer on Mental Disorder by anamax on Thursday September 13, 2012 @12:10AM (#4514755)
> There is a food shortage in Africa.

No, there's a distribution problem, but I'll play along.

> One way to solve this would be to kill 80% of the African population.

Nope. Killing 80% of the African population will not solve the food shortage. (It also won't solve the distribution problem.) Why? Because Africa's food production is roughly proportional to its population and not limited by anything that will be helped by killing lots of people.

The "end" of killing 80% of the African population is that 80% of the population has been killed. Some "good person" might have thought that some good (less starvation) would result from killing them, but the end was a lot of dead people who got killed by said good person.

Thanks for providing an example of where "he meant well" had a horrendous result, as it typically does.