> you can get far more mileage out of the naive models than people want to admit.
All models are wrong, but some models are useful, right? I'm a big fan of this phrase so much because I think it helps us remember that it's okay to be wrong.I feel like the biggest problem of first principles is that this is almost never where you start. Rather it is something you work towards. Where it then becomes an iterative process expanding/extrapolating out, then coming back in and refining. Low level knowledge is so beneficial, but also very difficult to obtain. It's even more difficult to see how much room is below you without ever having gone down.
And fully agreed on your reasoning on why these are good phrases to keep in mind. I think I would pile on to the "becomes an iterative process" to highlight that "starting from first principals" is more likely to be where folks start. With advanced solutions expanded to cover more and more details that the initial assumptions could gloss over.
I think this is largely justified, if only because "first principals" meaning "absolute foundation" are almost certainly still being discovered.
I think the idea is supposed to be to go back to the "first principals [that you would have been taught]." Which, yes, sometimes you will learn things that show these early teachings were wrong. Often, though, you can get far more mileage out of the naive models than people want to admit.
To that end, I think used judiciously, this has merit. Rarely does anything go against early teaching. It should lean on the specific assumptions and why they do or do not apply anymore, though.