send me your numbers then edgelord... o wait theyre not just numbers now that Ive asked for some. Go read up on futures markets - they were invented to service a legitimate, real world problem - yes deriviative markets of today have become abstract but its no as black and white as capitalists vs us.
Realistically large companies don't do this. They put their money in hedge funds, which are much less risk averse, which would assume that they are more actively putting the money into the economy.
This is not to say it's his fault. That's how our laws are written. But that is the point of OP. That our policies should be forcing him to sell and put that money back into the economy.
It would be at least as accurate to say it's as close as money can get to not existing at all. Policy should probably not be "forcing" people to realize gains that, in many cases (maybe not MS, but policy has to work for everyone), may as well be Monopoly money.
The only time money actually flows to the company is when stock is initially offered.
A company might be valued billions in the stock market, but this is not money that the company can work with.
> A company might be valued billions in the stock market, but this is not money that the company can work with.
Both of these statements are demonstrably false. Why do you think companies go public (which is quite troublesome) in the first place? Just vanity to see the billions they don't have access to? Or to allow investors to make money without helping the company in any way? It's clear why investors would come to a purely speculative market with no intrinsic value (e.g. crypto) but it's unclear why a company would offer their shares to be traded like a shitcoin.
Being public is the instrument for the company first and foremost. There's the IPO, then companies continuously issue and buyback stocks depending on the cashflow. Look e.g. at the graph of Tesla's outstanding shares [1]. Then companies also sell bonds or borrow money using their own stock as the collateral. The bigger valuation you have the more capital you have access to.
Not to mention that even in the OP's simplistic view of the market there is an actual "new value" aspect: if you buy stocks from a VC or a founder, they use it to fund the next startup.
[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/shares-...
Fair point about using stock as collateral though.
It wouldn't be called "Initial Public Offering" if it was the "Only Public Offering" like you suggest.
When I say initial offering, I mean whenever stock is newly (initially) issued - whether that's in IPO, after an IPO or also in a private offering. Not sure what the correct term would be.
My point was, money essentially only flows into the company at that point. E.g. company issues stock, investor A buys it.
When investor A sells to investor B, money only flows between these two investors. No money flows to the company.
Unless - as you have pointed out - company assumes the role of an investor in its own stock.
But the fact alone that a stock price is rising as such does not generate any new capital to work with for the company. And that is a point many people seem to misunderstand.
When Microsoft is worth 3.76 trillion USD, that doesn't mean that Microsoft has 3.76 trillion USD it can work with. That was the point I was trying to make.
The above is a mere byproduct of the market working. The market "works" by giving companies and entrepreneurs access to capital, the rest is a derivative of that. Otherwise you can as well trade postal stamps rather than stocks.
Either way the economy is not zero sum game where there's a fixed amount of money. If the stock market grows there is more money. That money reflects future expectations discounted to today but it's still more money.
On the original question, how does Ballmer being very wealthy impacts the rest of us, there is no easy answer. It depends on what he does with his money. It can be neutral, positive, or negative. The sentiment though seems to be mostly driven by jealousy and a sense of unfairness. It's in fashion these days (in some circles) to hate the "rich" (which is basically anyone better off than yourself more or less).