News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by gruez on Monday September 01, 2025 @11:15AM (#45093360)
>and it is wilful, they know full well it has no concept of truthfulness, yet they serve up its slop output directly into the faces of billions of people

Given that there's a disclaimer that the AI output shouldn't be treated as some sort of oracle for truth, and that the concept of "hallucinations" has been widely disseminated for years, why should AI companies be held liable? If so, should sites like cleverbot be held liable for libel as well? To take it to the extreme, should a magic 8-ball site be liable in case its prognostications fail to materialize?

Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by oxguy3 on Monday September 01, 2025 @11:27AM (#45093489)
The AI summaries in Google aren't presented as wild hallucinations; they show up in an authoritative looking box as an answer to the query you just typed. The New York Times wouldn't be able to get out of libel suits by adding a tiny disclaimer to their masthead; why should it be different for Google?
Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by gruez on Monday September 01, 2025 @11:31AM (#45093534)
>The New York Times wouldn't be able to get out of libel suits by adding a tiny disclaimer to their masthead; why should it be different for Google?

Fortune tellers and tarrot card readers are quite authoritative as well. They ostensibly claim to be able to tell the future, but they get away with it by adding a tiny disclaimer that the advice they dispense are for "entertainment purposes only".

Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by oxguy3 on Monday September 01, 2025 @11:54AM (#45093763)
Fortune tellers typically tell you extremely vague things that are designed to trick you into interpreting them favorably; you hear what you want to hear. "Someone new will come into your life soon" or "Something exciting will happen next week" are not claims that can be disproved.

They certainly don't make hyperspecific claims like "this YouTuber traveled to Israel and changed his mind about the war there, as documented in a video he posted on August 18".

Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by aDyslecticCrow on Monday September 01, 2025 @12:01PM (#45093827)
You can sue a fortune teller too if they tell people you're a sex offender and drink piss.
Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by gruez on Monday September 01, 2025 @12:05PM (#45093873)
Anyone can sue, but has there been a case of a fortune teller actually losing? What if there was no involvement from the fortune teller at all, like if the client asked "is my wife cheating on me", and all 3 cards drawn were in the affirmative?
Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by aDyslecticCrow on Monday September 01, 2025 @12:33PM (#45094166)
Fortune telling is a bad strawman and you know it. Fortune tellers talk with one person, give vague advice, and may destroy a relationship at worst.

If a Fortune teller published articles claiming false things about random prople, gave dangerous medical advice, claiming to be a Nigerian prince, or convinced you to put all your savings into bitcoin; the "entertainment purposes" shield dissolves quite quickly.

Google makes an authorative statement on top of the worlds most used search engine, in a similar way they previously did with Wikipedia for relevant topics.

The little disclaimer should not shield them from doing real tangible harm to people.

Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by antonvs on Monday September 01, 2025 @12:51PM (#45094362)
Fortune telling for profit is illegal in several big US states and other jurisdictions, including e.g. Pennsylvania and New York, for the same kinds of reasons being discussed. It’s not ok to make things up to make a profit unless you’re doing so purely for entertainment, i.e. it’s understood that the statements are fictional.

The Google disclaimer should probably be upfront and say something more like, “The following statements are fictional, provided for entertainment purposes only. Any resemblance to persons living or dead are purely coincidental.”

Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by const_cast on Monday September 01, 2025 @12:58PM (#45094427)
Yes, people have lost libel and defamation suits. Its not like being a fortune teller means you can magically lie.
Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by atq2119 on Monday September 01, 2025 @11:44AM (#45093662)
Google aren't advertising their search as "for entertainment purposes only" though.

And even if they did, it wouldn't really matter. The way Google search is overwhelmingly used in practice, misinformation spread by it is a public hazard and needs to be treated as such.

Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by gruez on Monday September 01, 2025 @11:55AM (#45093779)
>Google aren't advertising their search as "for entertainment purposes only" though.

So you accept that all of this is just a quibble over what the disclaimer says? Rather than "AI generated, might contain mistakes", it should just say "for entertainment purposes only" and they'll be in the clear?

Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by mattbuilds on Monday September 01, 2025 @11:36AM (#45093585)
That’s a false equivalency, sorry that some of us think companies should actually be responsible for the things they produce.
Re:Turns out Google made up an elaborate story about me by lupusreal on Monday September 01, 2025 @12:07PM (#45093889)
Gruez supports genocide.

DISCLAIMER: I often make shit up!