Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by wat10000 on Thursday August 28, 2025 @09:18PM
(#45058926)
"That's on them" is not acceptable for an engineer when lives are on the line. Part of your job is making people understand what they need to understand. If their lack of understanding means people die, then you need to do your job and figure out how to communicate effectively to the audience you have, not the audience you want.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by hinkley on Thursday August 28, 2025 @09:45PM
(#45059100)
There’s a famous speech someone related from their civil engineering professor, where the professor basically said, if I pass you in this class I am effectively giving you a license to kill. So some of you will not be passing.
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by fhdbdnfnndnn on Thursday August 28, 2025 @10:08PM
(#45059245)
The assumption of competency goes both ways. The NASA personnel should have been able to understand a very standard slide in their field, that any college-educated fluent English speaker would have been able to grasp.
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by wat10000 on Thursday August 28, 2025 @10:01PM
(#45059203)
My CS undergrad was in the engineering college and so I had a mandatory engineering seminar that was basically "don't get people killed with your work." We covered Challenger, Hyatt Regency, and some other classic failures. I've mostly avoided working on life-critical software so it's not an immediate concern, but that sense of responsibility still stuck with me.
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by hinkley on Thursday August 28, 2025 @10:52PM
(#45059594)
Also attended an engineering school. I had to take way too much chem and physics. It was weird.
I can be kind of a pain in the ass when it comes to details so I’ve worked on a couple such projects. It’s sobering, but also I think, “better me than” half a dozen corner cutters at my last two jobs. They could do much worse.
That said, I stayed on a commercial aerospace project about 14 months after I didn’t really want to be there because people kept saying the wrong things in meetings and thinking they sounded right.
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by gjejcjekdnfnwja on Thursday August 28, 2025 @09:21PM
(#45058938)
People with a high school level education should not have been making life and death decisions about the Space Shuttle.
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by wat10000 on Thursday August 28, 2025 @09:25PM
(#45058971)
First of all, is that actually their level of education or are you just making stuff up?
Second, that's irrelevant to my point that the engineer is responsible for communicating, not just figuring stuff out. You cannot say "if you don't get it, that's your problem" when their not getting it means people die.
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by gjejcjekdnfnwja on Thursday August 28, 2025 @09:30PM
(#45058997)
The slide in the OP is a completely standard way of commumicating information in the aerospace industry. If the NASA personnel had problems understanding this slide, then they also had problems understanding virtually every other piece of technical info that was ever communicated to them by a third party. College level reading comprehension means being able to understand nuance, which this slide conveys.
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by wat10000 on Thursday August 28, 2025 @09:32PM
(#45059011)
All you're doing here is convincing me that this wasn't a one-off and the aerospace industry has a pervasive problem with communication.
Re:Death by PowerPoint: the slide that killed seven people
by fhdbdnfnndnn on Thursday August 28, 2025 @09:40PM
(#45059073)
The average IQ and level of English proficiency is much higher in aerospace than it is building web apps.