Re:In Defense of Judging Startups Based on VC Dollars Raised
by Josh2600hz on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @11:25AM
(#4505875)
The graph here doesn't prove causality (or even really a correlation).
On the one hand, PG argues that funding is not a good indicator of success, and on the other hand, the author here is saying look how successful all of these funded companies are! It's a false equivalency.
The author is doing exactly what PG talked about, glossing back over history with 20/20 hindsight. As indicated, even the prestigious YC has ~75% of returns from 2 startups.
The article doesn't talk about how many companies failed, spectacularly, in order for those other organizations to succeed. Cuil flamed out $100M+, and there are countless other examples.
I'm not saying the author is wrong, only that this didn't prove causality to me; ergo funding=success.
On the one hand, PG argues that funding is not a good indicator of success, and on the other hand, the author here is saying look how successful all of these funded companies are! It's a false equivalency.
The author is doing exactly what PG talked about, glossing back over history with 20/20 hindsight. As indicated, even the prestigious YC has ~75% of returns from 2 startups.
The article doesn't talk about how many companies failed, spectacularly, in order for those other organizations to succeed. Cuil flamed out $100M+, and there are countless other examples.
I'm not saying the author is wrong, only that this didn't prove causality to me; ergo funding=success.